The Essence of Care: Versatility as an Adaptive Response to Challenges in the Delivery of Quality Aged Care by Personal Care Attendants

Abstract

Objective The strategies adopted by personal care attendants (PCAs) to deliver quality care when faced with challenges potentially impacting clinical outcomes were assessed using phenomenological methods. Background In Australia, recent outcry of unsatisfactory standards of care in residential facilities has instigated a national public inquiry. This study investigated how PCAs adapted to challenges in stressful and ambiguous everyday work scenarios to deliver quality care. Method A phenomenological approach was used to obtain insights into PCAs’ experiences, perceptions, opinions, and decision processes for enacting care. Ten PCAs working in rural-based residential aged care were interviewed using a novel scenario construction task with thematic and co-occurrence network mapping applied to derive insights. Results Seven themes were identified, revealing that participants formed close relationships with residents, influencing care provision but blurring personal boundaries. Key contextual factors in scenarios highlighted inadequate staffing and procedures, inadequate training, challenging residents, time poverty, and low support. Individually directed adaptive strategies were used to alleviate dissonance and maintain emotional resilience, including dynamic risk assessment involving rule breaking. Conclusion The findings suggest that in negotiating care delivery, PCAs strive to optimize rule-based compliance with safety, efficiency, and individualized attention to provide “good enough” care with fluidity. Implications for policy and practice are considered. Application Findings have implications for workforce development in the context of ever-increasing industry pressures. Findings identified challenging scenarios and role complexity, with decision-making occurring as a fluid and ongoing process across a flexible boundary of risk assessment influencing interactions between PCAs, registered nurses, and clients.

Authority gradients between rail network controllers, train crew and track workers in Australia and New Zealand: motivations and behaviours

“…It involves generating challenging scenarios using drawings and is particularly useful for eliciting knowledge from content experts (Roth et al 2020). The SITT has been used to elicit knowledge from various industries, including health care (Naweed et al 2021), aviation (Kingshott & Naweed 2018), and rail (Naweed 2013).…”

From dreams to reality: a phenomenological study of the psychological contracts of ex-military personnel in the Australian Defence Force

“…This was done with the goal to give the reader an accurate understanding of the essence of the experience (Moustakas, 1994), in this case, what ex-military personnel who have experienced contract breach have as common experiences in their formation. To this end, using phenomenology allowed us to obtain rich and substantive insights into the decision processes, experiences, perceptions, and opinions of a social unit (Cane, McCarthy, & Halawi, 2010; Curry, Nembhard, & Bradley, 2009; Ferroff, Mavin, Bates, & Murray, 2012; Naweed, Stahlut, & O’Keeffe, 2021). This detailed research enquiry was matched to the problem, namely, to understand what meaning ex-military personnel ascribed to their experience of psychological contract formation and breach at major military organisations.…”