The Effects of September 11 on Traumatized Refugees: Reactivation of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder

Abstract

Secondary traumatization from the tragic events of September 11, 2001 was studied among an ethnically diverse group of refugees who had been previously traumatized in their native war torn countries. A brief clinically oriented questionnaire was developed and administered to a clinic population of Vietnamese, Cambodian, Laotian, Bosnian and Somalian refugees in the Intercultural Psychiatric Program at Oregon Health & Science University. Traumatic symptoms and responses to the widely televised images from September 11 were assessed among the five ethnic groups, and the differential responses among patients with posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, and schizophrenia also were assessed. The strongest responses were among Bosnian and Somalian patients with PTSD, and the Somalis had the greatest deterioration in their subjective sense of safety and security. Regardless of ethnic group, PTSD patients reacted most intensely, and patients with schizophrenia the least. Although patients largely returned to their baseline clinical status after two to three months, this study shows that cross-cultural reactivation of trauma has a significant clinical impact. It is essential that clinicians anticipate PTSD symptom reactivation among refugees when they are reexposed to significant traumatic stimuli.

Mental Health Consequences of September 11: A Five-Year Review of the Behavioral Sciences Literature

“…Another study (Kinzie et al 2002) evaluated refugees from five countries (Bosnia, Cambodia, Laos, Somalia and Vietnam) living in Portland, Oregon. Nine hundred refugees were enrolled in a psychiatric clinic.…”

Evaluating the SF-36 Health Survey (Version 2) in Older Vietnamese Americans

“…Older Vietnamese immigrants are at particularly high risk for physical and mental distress as a result of migrating later in life (age >55 years) and because of premigration trauma suffered when they were in communist labor camps and refugee camps. A high prevalence of depression and posttraumatic stress syndrome as a result of torture and imprisonment has been documented (Buchwald, Manson, Dinges, Keane, & Kinzie, 1993;Hinton et al, 1993;Kinzie, Boehnlein, Riley, & Sparr, 2002;Kinzie et al, 1982;Mollica, Wyshak, de Marneffe, Khuon, & Lavelle, 1987;Smith Fawzi et al, 1997). A total of 23% of Vietnamese women in a study in California were estimated to have clinical depression (McPhee et al, 1997).…”

“Warriors”: Impact of a Powerful Television Drama on the Psychological Health of U.K. Bosnia Peacekeepers

“…Nevertheless, the advice for those who are distressed by such images to turn off the TV remains common sense (29).…”