The Effects of Musical Training on Child Development: a Randomized Trial of El Sistema in Venezuela

Abstract

Many studies have explored the links between music and children’s outcomes; however, study designs have not been sufficiently rigorous to support causal findings. This study aims to assess the effects of a large-scale music program on children’s developmental functioning in the context of high rates of exposure to violence. The paper describes the results of an experimental evaluation of Venezuela’s National System of Youth and Children’s Orchestras. The curriculum of the program, better known as “El Sistema,” emphasizes social interactions through group instruction and group performances. The randomized control trial was conducted in 16 music centers between May 2012 and November 2013. In total, 2914 children ages 6–14 participated in the experiment, with approximately half receiving an offer of admission to the program in September 2012 and half in September 2013. The treatment group children participated for one semester more than the control group children. After 1 year, full-sample ITT estimates indicate improved self-control (by 0.10 standard deviations) and reduced behavioral difficulties (by 0.08 standard deviations), both significant at 10% after controlling for multiple hypothesis testing. There were no full-sample effects on other domains. Sub-sample effects are larger among (1) children with less-educated mothers and (2) boys, especially those exposed to violence at baseline. In the latter subgroup, we find lower levels of aggressive behavior. We find that the program improved self-control and reduced behavioral difficulties, with the effects concentrated among subgroups of vulnerable children. The results suggest the importance of devising mechanisms to target resources to the most vulnerable children.Trial registration: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02369315 Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s11121-016-0727-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

The early adolescent brain on music: analysis of functional dynamics reveals engagement of orbitofrontal cortex reward system

“…We may speculate that the capability of music listening to stimulate and strongly attract the reward OFC reward system during adolescence might make music able to modulate the development and the function of top-down reward regulation of this brain region. This would be consistent with studies showing the effects of music training -and therefore continuous music exposure -on cortical thickness maturation in OFC (Hudziak et al 2014) and inhibitory control (Moreno et al 2011;Alemán et al 2017;Holochwost et al 2017;Fasano et al 2019) in children and adolescents. Considering the vulnerability of this transition phase of life, the impact of music listening on the reward brain network should be considered in the clinical context.…”

Associations of physical activity and gross motor skills with executive function in preschool children from low‐income South African settings

“…For example, executive functions are susceptible to change, with interventions successfully improving executive function performance (e.g. after music training: Alemán et al, ; Rituals: Rybanska, Mckay, Jong, & Whitehouse, ) and structured physical activity programmes (Xiong et al, ). However, some differences are also apparent.…”

Increased engagement of the cognitive control network associated with music training in children during an fMRI Stroop task

“…A recent longitudinal study with children found that random assignment in an after-school music training program was associated with enhanced performance on several tasks of cognitive control and response inhibition [ 31 ]. However, an effect of music-based interventions on measures of executive function was not replicated in another large-scale study of children between the ages of 6–14 [ 32 ].…”