The Effects of Cultural Based Text Types in Reading Comprehension

Abstract

Background and Purpose: This research aims to investigate the effects of Malay, Chinese and Indian cultural based text types on reading comprehension.
 
 Methodology: An exploratory case study research design was employed to explore the use of cultural schemata in reading comprehension of three types of cultural text format: narrative, descriptive and info graphic. The purposive sampling method was used to select participants based on their ethnicities, English proficiency level, and their scores in prior knowledge assessment and retelling assessment. A total of 15 students, between 11- 12 years old, were selected. The retelling technique in written form, a comprehension test and an interview protocol were used as instruments to gather data in this research and they were analysed both quantitatively and qualitatively.
 
 Findings: The overall findings have shown that the comprehension test scores showed better performance in info graphic texts. However, the retelling assessment scores showed better performance in retelling narrative texts. The participants’ main reason for text incomprehensibility was due to the unfamiliar cultural content regardless of the types of text format
 .
 Contributions: This study aids teachers in their pedagogical decisions when selecting and adapting cultural texts for reading comprehension
 
 Keywords: Comprehension test, cultural schemata, reading comprehension, retelling assessment, text types.
 Cite as: Thirunavukarasu, I., & Raja Harun, R. N. S. (2021). The effects of cultural based text types in reading comprehension. Journal of Nusantara Studies, 6(1), 1-23. http://dx.doi.org/10.24200/jonus.vol6iss1pp1-23

The Use of Local Literary Texts as Reading Materials in English Language Classrooms: An Analysis of Teachers’ Perspectives

“…Malaysian primary school pupils are noted to be generally struggling with ESL readings with a common traceable factor which is an issue of text selection (e.g. Puteh, Mohd Zin & Ismail, 2012;Abdul Hamid & Mohd Shah, 2017;Mihat, Azman & Or, 2018;Mustaffar et al, 2019;Muhammad, Latiff Azmi & Hassan, 2020;Thirunavukarasu & Raja Harun, 2021). Malaysian students continue to face difficulty when dealing with foreign cultural elements, particularly in its comprehension.…”

The Use of CEFR-Aligned Textbooks among English Language Teachers: A Systematic Literature Review

“…In general, various effective strategies can be carried out by teachers so that teachers can help to improve student's English proficiency (Ya Syak et al, 2023). This is also supported by Thirunavukarasu and Harun (2021), who said that the teacher's ability to create effective strategies in the classroom can have a large and positive impact on the student learning process. This means that it is very important for all teachers to use effective strategies that suit the needs and abilities of students so that the learning that takes place can increase the level of student mastery.…”