The effectiveness of newsletters in accountants' client relations with small business managers

Abstract

PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to evaluate the effectiveness of one of accounting practitioners' most widely‐used client relations techniques. By evaluating the effectiveness of the newsletters that accountants provide to small business managers, the paper critically assesses their role in contributing to accountants' overall strategy for developing relations with their substantial small business manager client base.Design/methodology/approachSemi‐structured interviews were conducted with ten accountants who have provided newsletters to small business clients. The interviews were motivated by the results of a questionnaire administered to a sample of small business managers. The interview findings offer valuable insights into accountants' rationale for providing newsletters to their small business clients and accountants' assessment of the effectiveness of newsletters as a client relations technique. Analysis of the findings is informed by media richness theory.FindingsThe findings indicate that, despite their apparent popularity amongst professional accounting firms, newsletters are an ineffective method for developing relations with accountants' small business manager clients. The effectiveness of accountants' newsletters is diminished by the generic impersonal nature of the newsletter content that managers of small firms cannot relate to their own circumstances and by newsletters' technical accounting and tax content that small business managers have difficulty understanding.Originality/valueThe paper contributes to redressing a gap in research regarding the effectiveness of newsletters in accountants' relations with the economically significant small business sector, while better informing practitioners' development of their advisory relationship with small business managers. Rapidly emerging social media alternatives to the widespread practice of distributing newsletters to facilitate relations with small business clients are introduced as an emergent phenomenon.

Social Media Use and Academic Performance: A Study on Undergraduate Accounting Students of Bangladesh

“…In that sense, access to social media and communication are relevant. Social media such as Twitter and LinkedIn allow the users to cope with virtual communication systems in this age of information technology (Stone, 2012). Additionally, through social media people become accustomed to the culture of providing instant feedback with online chats and real-time messaging.…”

Integrated Reporting in an Internet and Social Media Communication Environment: Conceptual Insights

“…Subsequent studies further developed and empirically tested the criteria (Lodhia 2006(Lodhia , 2010. Media richness theoretical perspectives have also been applied in studies of the impact of corporate social and environmental website disclosures (Cho et al 2009) and communications between accountants and the small business sector (Stone 2011(Stone , 2012. The media richness framework is applied to a different context in this paper, that of integrated reporting, thereby expanding its explanatory potential.…”

Communication and customer retention: A case of an accounting organisation

“…According to the media richness theory, there are two main types of media, a rich media and a lean media (Aljukhadar, & Senecal, 2017). A rich media is used to communicate information that can be found as confusing or hard to explain in a short amount of time (Stone, 2012). Lean media is used to explain information that is not confusing and understood by any party they are communicating with (Kishi, 2008).…”

“…Television advertisements and radio are used as a form of lean media, as it reaches a range of people that can understand the information. Face-to-face and telephone communication are the richest forms of media, allowing for immediate feedback, where the other party can clarify the point they are trying to convey (Stone, 2012). Written forms of communication have a varied amount of richness (Stone, 2011).…”

“…Letters that are specifically written for an individual are richer than one written for a general group of people. Lean media does not allow for immediate feedback or verbal and non-verbal cues that a richer communication method may have (Stone, 2012).…”