The Effect of Traumatic Experiences of North Korean Adolescent Refugees upon Their Negative Health Perception: Focusing on Multiple Moderating Effect of Problem-Focused versus Social Support-Focused Coping Strategies
Abstract:The health problems of North Korean (NK) refugees living a new life after surviving the dangers of life and death traumas is an issue that must be taken very seriously. Adolescent refugees may be particularly vulnerable to adverse physical and mental health issues because of major physical, cognitive, and psychosocial developmental changes during adolescence. This study examines the positive roles two active coping strategies—problem-focused coping and social support-focused coping—can play in NK refugee adole… Show more
“…This group had a high trauma experience and high comorbidity of social withdrawal and depression. In general, discrimination and exclusion exist in the job market for North Korean refugees in Korean society, which makes it very difficult for them to achieve and succeed professionally (Ryu, 2020). They have a high positive career identity, but they are expected to struggle alone due to a lack of support from their surroundings compared to groups with High growth or adaptive aggression.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…North Korean Adolescent refugees commonly experience large and small traumatic events while living in North Korea or deciding and implementing their escapes. Ninety-eight percent of adolescent refugees from North Korea report traumatic exposure (Yang, 2018) to forced labor, police surveillance, witnessing public execution, and confinement and torture in detention centers before leaving their country (Nam et al, 2021; Ryu, 2020; Ryu & Park, 2018; Ryu & Yang, 2021; Son et al, 2019), and fear of death, lack of food, severe cold, forced repatriation, seclusion, and death of family during their migration (Son et al, 2019; Yang, 2018).…”
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Unfortunately, however, very few studies have revealed a specific relationship between PTG and mental health problems of North Korean adolescent refugees. In some qualitative studies, the relationships were investigated to an extent of identifying the coexistence of mental health problems, such as depression, withdrawal, and aggression with PTG (Ryu, 2020; Ryu & Yang, 2021). Although this variable-centered approach may be useful for studying the general trends, there is a limitation in overlooking the possibility that different subgroups may share the same symptom profile within the group.…”
Objective: This study is to explore identifiable psychological differences and predictors for the subgroup of refugees who at a very early age moved from a totalitarian country to a westernized democracy, ultimately to improve policies and reduce the maladaptation of refugees to a new society. More specifically, it is to fill in significant gaps in understanding and predicting refugee tendencies toward depression, social withdrawal, aggression, and posttraumatic growth. Method: Latent class analysis was conducted to identify subgroups based on symptom profiles within a sample of 201 North Korean adolescent refugees residing in South Korea. Results: Four subgroups were identified: (a) High growth, (b) Low trauma with high adaptive aggression, (c) Low trauma with high social withdrawal/depression, and (d) High trauma with high comorbidity. Predictors were physical health, self-esteem, peer support, teacher support, and school adjustment. Conclusion: Current refugee policies in South Korea would benefit from refining services to allow customization to the specific needs and characteristics of each adolescent rather than continue the current model of homogeneity.
Clinical Impact StatementDespite similar stressors and traumas during childhood refugee experiences, integration into a new society can be improved by recognizing and addressing the four primary tendencies among refugees who are now adolescents. Customized support and interest based on a target-centered approach would play an effective role in the growth of the North Korean adolescent refugees.
“…This group had a high trauma experience and high comorbidity of social withdrawal and depression. In general, discrimination and exclusion exist in the job market for North Korean refugees in Korean society, which makes it very difficult for them to achieve and succeed professionally (Ryu, 2020). They have a high positive career identity, but they are expected to struggle alone due to a lack of support from their surroundings compared to groups with High growth or adaptive aggression.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…North Korean Adolescent refugees commonly experience large and small traumatic events while living in North Korea or deciding and implementing their escapes. Ninety-eight percent of adolescent refugees from North Korea report traumatic exposure (Yang, 2018) to forced labor, police surveillance, witnessing public execution, and confinement and torture in detention centers before leaving their country (Nam et al, 2021; Ryu, 2020; Ryu & Park, 2018; Ryu & Yang, 2021; Son et al, 2019), and fear of death, lack of food, severe cold, forced repatriation, seclusion, and death of family during their migration (Son et al, 2019; Yang, 2018).…”
mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Unfortunately, however, very few studies have revealed a specific relationship between PTG and mental health problems of North Korean adolescent refugees. In some qualitative studies, the relationships were investigated to an extent of identifying the coexistence of mental health problems, such as depression, withdrawal, and aggression with PTG (Ryu, 2020; Ryu & Yang, 2021). Although this variable-centered approach may be useful for studying the general trends, there is a limitation in overlooking the possibility that different subgroups may share the same symptom profile within the group.…”
Objective: This study is to explore identifiable psychological differences and predictors for the subgroup of refugees who at a very early age moved from a totalitarian country to a westernized democracy, ultimately to improve policies and reduce the maladaptation of refugees to a new society. More specifically, it is to fill in significant gaps in understanding and predicting refugee tendencies toward depression, social withdrawal, aggression, and posttraumatic growth. Method: Latent class analysis was conducted to identify subgroups based on symptom profiles within a sample of 201 North Korean adolescent refugees residing in South Korea. Results: Four subgroups were identified: (a) High growth, (b) Low trauma with high adaptive aggression, (c) Low trauma with high social withdrawal/depression, and (d) High trauma with high comorbidity. Predictors were physical health, self-esteem, peer support, teacher support, and school adjustment. Conclusion: Current refugee policies in South Korea would benefit from refining services to allow customization to the specific needs and characteristics of each adolescent rather than continue the current model of homogeneity.
Clinical Impact StatementDespite similar stressors and traumas during childhood refugee experiences, integration into a new society can be improved by recognizing and addressing the four primary tendencies among refugees who are now adolescents. Customized support and interest based on a target-centered approach would play an effective role in the growth of the North Korean adolescent refugees.
“…Forced migration during adolescence has been found to be riskier than any other period of an individual's life (Beiser et al, 1995). Refugees in the adolescent period may be particularly vulnerable to adverse physical and mental health issues compared to adult refugees, since adloscents are in an unstable period characterised by major physical, cognitive, and psychosocial changes (Ryu, 2020). It is also unknown whether adolescents are predisposed to higher levels of mental health problems as a result of trauma, given their limited life experience in dealing with such situations.…”
This scoping review examines known associations between potential traumatic experiences and mental health outcomes among adolescent refugees. Little is known about the type and severity of traumatic experiences among adolescent refugees and whether the type and severity of these experiences are associated with poor mental health. Five electronic databases were searched to identify relevant peer-reviewed articles. Inclusion criteria were: 1) trauma was the predictor variable of the article, 2) at least one of two selected mental health conditions (depression and anxiety) was an outcome variable of the study, 3) the quantitative relationship between trauma and mental health was discussed; 4) participants of the study were adolescent refugees or asylum seekers; 5) the article was published between January 1, 2011 and August 30, 2020; 6) and written in English. Adolescents aged 12-18 of all genders were included in this review. Of 3319 potentially relevant articles identified, 11 articles were included. All the included studies employed a cross-sectional study design. Adolescent refugees experienced a variety of traumatic events, such as physical and sexual violence, war-related events, natural disasters, migration-related events, and verbal and emotional abuse. The review found a positive association between trauma exposure and poor mental health outcomes of depression and anxiety in all included studies across diverse adolescent refugee populations. The findings suggest that effective intervention strategies should be implemented to meet the needs of children and adolescent refugees as a vulnerable group in the host community as they adjust to the language, cultural, and school barriers and to support overall growth and development.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.