“…This type of work produced numerous hypotheses about the RE effect 58 -62 and has greatly increased the level of understanding about critical factors important for the formation, growth, and adhesion of alumina scales. More recent studies have used 18 O tracers, 29,34,[63][64][65] photograph-stimulated laser spectroscopy (PSLS), 47,48 and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) 19,20,34,35,38,40,42,45,49,51,53,54,56 to more carefully study the RE effect. However, these comparative or mechanistic studies rarely discussed the relative performance of RE additions or how to optimize the effects for alloy development.…”