The effect of sleep restriction, with or without high‐intensity interval exercise, on behavioural alertness and mood state in young healthy males

Abstract

SummaryMood state and alertness are negatively affected by sleep loss, and can be positively influenced by exercise. However, the potential mitigating effects of exercise on sleep‐loss‐induced changes in mood state and alertness have not been studied comprehensively. Twenty‐four healthy young males were matched into one of three, 5‐night sleep interventions: normal sleep (NS; total sleep time (TST) per night = 449 ± 22 min), sleep restriction (SR; TST = 230 ± 5 min), or sleep restriction and exercise (SR + EX; TST = 235 ± 5 min, plus three sessions of high‐intensity interval exercise (HIIE)). Mood state was assessed using the profile of mood states (POMS) and a daily well‐being questionnaire. Alertness was assessed using psychomotor vigilance testing (PVT). Following the intervention, POMS total mood disturbance scores significantly increased for both the SR and SR + EX groups, and were greater than the NS group (SR vs NS; 31.0 ± 10.7 A.U., [4.4–57.7 A.U.], p = 0.020; SR + EX vs NS; 38.6 ± 14.9 A.U., [11.1–66.1 A.U.], p = 0.004). The PVT reaction times increased in the SR (p = 0.049) and SR + EX groups (p = 0.033) and the daily well‐being questionnaire revealed increased levels of fatigue in both groups (SR; p = 0.041, SR + EX; p = 0.026) during the intervention. Despite previously demonstrated physiological benefits of performing three sessions of HIIE during five nights of sleep restriction, the detriments to mood, wellness, and alertness were not mitigated by exercise in this study. Whether alternatively timed exercise sessions or other exercise protocols could promote more positive outcomes on these factors during sleep restriction requires further research.

Rope Skipping or Badminton? The Effect of Exercise on Sleep Quality and Fatigue in University Students

“…It needs to be noted that the operationalization of assessing fatigue, alertness, and mood state may be the main cause of the mixed study results. For instance, we measured them via a questionnaire that contains one question for each variable, while others measured fatigue using other questionnaires or measured alertness objectively via psychomotor vigilance testing [44]. Additionally, the intensity and the content of exercises also varied.…”

Frontiers and hotspots of high-intensity interval exercise in children and adolescents: text mining and knowledge domain visualization

“…This cluster focuses on the cognitive benefits, but the concerns of the small number of studies and large heterogeneity and the time-course of effects on cognition, following HIIE, are not well-understood. Moreover, in a special setting, e.g., regular short sleep, the consensus on the cognitive performance of exercise and its potential therapeutic benefits remains contested ( Saner et al, 2020 ; Saner et al, 2023 ; You et al, 2023 ; You et al, 2023 ). MICT appears to induce more cognitive benefits than HIIT despite short sleep ( You et al, 2023 ).…”

Focus on insomnia, nightmares and mental health

“…Saner et al (2024) studied the effects of sleep restriction (with or without high‐intensity exercise) on behavioral alertness and mood in young healthy males. 24 healthy young males were matched into one of three, 5‐night sleep interventions: normal sleep, sleep restriction down to less than four hours or sleep restriction and exercise.…”