Pollen grains have the potential to be effective plant-based biorenewable fillers in polymer matrices due to their high modulus, strength, chemical stability, and unique nanoscale architectures. In this work, we present evidence for the effectiveness of pollen as a reinforcing filler in epoxy matrices, characterized as a function of pollen loading and surface treatment. Composites prepared with unmodified native defatted ragweed pollen (D) displayed decreased mechanical properties and increasing glass transition temperatures (T g ) with increasing pollen loading. A soft interphase was observed to form around native pollen that is likely due to incompletely cured epoxy, resulting in decreased mechanical properties. However, pollen treated via a common base-acid (BA) surface preparation was a load-bearing, toughening filler in epoxy composites, displaying simultaneously increased tensile strength (by 47%) and strain at break (by 70%), improving interfacial morphology (absence of soft interphase), and increasing T g at 10 wt% pollen loading. Elastic modulus improves by 14% with 10 wt% BA pollen loading, and fitting of the modulus with the Halpin-Tsai and Counto models results in an estimated pollen exine modulus of 8 GPa, the first reported pollen modulus measurement from composite studies. Improvements in mechanical properties in BA pollen versus D pollen likely result due to crosslinks with the epoxy matrix due to the presence of protic functional groups (hydroxyls or carboxyls) on the BA surface. BAtreated ragweed pollen shows promise as a toughening filler for imparting higher strength to polymers without increasing mass.