Candidate OSPAR/ICES recommended biomarkers at the level of the individual in Mytilus edulis for determination of good environmental status for MSFD were evaluated against contaminant levels at sites around Ireland. The sites chosen ranged from moderate to low pollution levels, but the actual ranking of the sites varied according to the contaminant levels present. At the most contaminated site, Cork, 4 out of 16 contaminants exceeded the EAC, while at Shannon, no EACs were exceeded. The SOS assay suggested that Cork was the healthiest site with a LT 50 of 17.6 days, while SOS for Shannon was 15.6 days. Likewise, condition factors varied among sites and did not always correspond to contaminant-based status. There may be uncertainty in assigning status around the not good:good boundary. This raises potential difficulties not only in the biomarker/contaminant load relationship but also in the reliability of the biomarkers themselves and hence barriers meeting compliance levels.Keywords: OSPAR; ICES; MSFD compliance; Mytilus edulis; Biomarkers; contaminants;
IntroductionThe main objective of the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD) [2008/56/EC] is to maintain good environmental status for marine waters, habitats and resources delivered in an integrated ecosystem based approach. In general current water quality assessments for hazardous substances in Ireland and elsewhere relied solely on chemical analysis alone but it is widely accepted through the Oslo and Paris Commission (OSPAR) and the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES) that chemical monitoring alone is no longer sufficient to assess pollution impacts in the marine environment and that integration of chemical and biological effects data is essential to provide an insight into the actual health status of the ecosystem. In recent years OSPAR and ICES have increased their focus on the integration of biological and chemical data, this being a key reporting requirement under the MSFD (8.2). Integration of such measurements forms an important element in linking contaminants and ecological responses and in assessing the overall quality of the marine environment. Over the last few years a wide range of biomarkers have been employed in monitoring to provide early warning signals for potential contamination.The blue mussel, Mytilus edulis has been extensively used as an indicator of environmental pollution due to its sedentary and filterfeeding nature and its ability to accumulate chemical contaminants from the seawater, from resuspended sediment, and from particulate food material (Moore et al., 2004). The Mussel watch concept, first proposed by Goldberg (1975) has been adopted by many countries including Ireland whereby mussels are used as sentinel organisms of contaminant exposure. As well as contaminant detection in tissues, a range of biomarkers can be used in order to assess impacts on the individual mussel. As part of the ecosystem based approach, an integrated assessment strategy for mussels (Thain et al., 2008) has been put for...