The effect of low-abundance OTU filtering methods on the reliability and variability of microbial composition assessed by 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing

Abstract

PCR amplicon sequencing may lead to detection of spurious operational taxonomic units (OTUs), inflating estimates of gut microbial diversity. There is no consensus in the analytical approach as to what filtering methods should be applied to remove low-abundance OTUs; moreover, few studies have investigated the reliability of OTU detection within replicates. Here, we investigated the reliability of OTU detection (% agreement in detecting OTU in triplicates) and accuracy of their quantification (assessed by coefficient of variation (CV)) in human stool specimens. Stool samples were collected from 12 participants 22–55 years old. We applied several methods for filtering low-abundance OTUs and determined their impact on alpha-diversity and beta-diversity metrics. The reliability of OTU detection without any filtering was only 44.1% (SE=0.9) but increased after filtering low-abundance OTUs. After filtering OTUs with <0.1% abundance in the dataset, the reliability increased to 87.7% (SE=0.6) but at the expense of removing 6.97% reads from the dataset. When filtering was based on individual sample, the reliability increased to 73.1% after filtering OTUs with <10 copies while removing only 1.12% of reads. High abundance OTUs (>10 copies in sample) had lower CV, indicating better accuracy of quantification than low-abundance OTUs. Excluding very low-abundance OTUs had a significant impact on alpha-diversity metrics sensitive to the presence of rare species (observed OTUs, Chao1) but had little impact on relative abundance of major phyla and families and alpha-diversity metrics accounting for both richness and evenness (Shannon, Inverse Simpson). To increase the reliability of microbial composition, we advise removing OTUs with <10 copies in individual samples, particularly in studies where only one subsample per specimen is available for analysis.

Evaluating the Efficiency of 16S-ITS-23S operon Sequencing: A Comparison of Primer Pairs, Sequencing Platforms, and Taxonomic Classifiers

“…Generally, applying MM-based approaches led to a higher incidence of false positives, aligning with the ndings of Cuscó et al [49]. To address the issue of false positives in MM-based methods, based on the F1 scores, we propose implementing a relative abundance cut-off of 0.01%, which is consistent with similar studies in the eld of amplicon sequencing [72,73]. This approach proved effective for evenly mixed mock communities like ATCC, MCAP, and MCGD.…”

Reproductive Tract Microbial Transitions from Late Gestation to Early Postpartum Using 16S rRNA Metagenetic Profiling in First-Pregnancy Heifers

“…The copyright holder for this preprint this version posted June 9, 2024. ; https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.08.598098 doi: bioRxiv preprint Alpha diversity metrics, including sample coverage, observed OTUs, and Inverse Simpson diversity estimates, provided valuable insights into community richness and diversity [27]. The lower diversity in the Utrpost group indicated a shift in the uterine microbial landscape, potentially influenced by postpartum physiological changes and the initiation of uterine involution.…”

Change of the vaginal microbiome with oral contraceptive therapy in women with polycystic ovary syndrome: a 6-month longitudinal cohort study

“…The number of reads for each sample was normalized to that of the sample with the smallest sequence ( n = 41,439). OTUs with < 10 copies in individual samples were excluded for the reliability and accuracy [ 19 ]. A sensitivity analysis was performed based on the amplicon sequence variants (ASVs) with the DADA2 method [ 20 ] through QIIME2 software.…”