The Effect of Intuitive Advice Justification on Advice Taking

Abstract

How do you respond when receiving advice from somebody with the argumentation "my gut tells me so" or "this is what my intuition says"? Most likely, you would find this justification insufficient and disregard the advice. Are there also situations where people do appreciate such intuitive advice and change their opinion accordingly? A growing number of authors write about the power of intuition in solving problems, showing that intuitively made decisions can be of higher quality than decisions based on analytical reasoning. We want to know if decision makers, when receiving advice based on an intuitive cognitive process, also recognize the value of such advice. Is advice justified by intuition necessarily followed to a lesser extent than an advice justified by analysis? Furthermore, what are the important factors influencing the effect of intuitive justification on advice taking? Participants across three studies show that utilization of intuitive advice varies depending on advisor seniority and type of task for which the advice is given. Summarizing, the results suggest that decision makers a priori doubt the value of intuitive advice and only assess it as accurate if other cues in the advice setting corroborate this. Intuitively justified advice is utilized more if it comes from a senior advisor. In decision tasks with experiential products, intuitively justified advice can even have more impact than analytically justified advice.

Unpacking the Black Box of Family Business Advising: Insights From Psychology

“…In addition to advice attributes, advisor attributes deserve more attention among family firm researchers. While prior family firm research has focused on advisor attributes such as their formal versus informal status (Naldi et al, 2015) and their professional backgrounds (e.g., Barbera & Hasso, 2013; Strike, 2013), psychology research has revealed additional important advisor attributes, such as expertise, trustworthiness, confidence, similarity (Feng & Feng, 2013), seniority (Tzioti et al, 2014), and motives (van Swol, 2009), which all affect the advice taking. Given that family firm decision makers are typically considered to be reluctant to take advice (Michel & Kammerlander, 2015; Naldi et al, 2015), family firm researchers and practitioners should aim to understand which advisor attributes are preferred by those individuals and why.…”

Exploring the skill of recruiting in the Australian Football League

“…Indeed, studies conducted in the Netherlands found that advice based on intuition is generally doubted, unless it is received from people with seniority, where it is utilised to a greater extent. 41 Additionally, a study on the role of advice in decision making more generally found that people who hold greater knowledge in a particular area are more likely to discount advice, placing greater significance on their personal opinion. 42 While the recruiter-coach relationship was seen as an influence on the approach to recruit selection, it is possible that this relationship is also reciprocal.…”

Managerial decision making in marketing: The next research frontier

“…Tzioti, Van Osselaer, and Wierenga (2010) found that the first option (using intuition-driven arguments, such as "my gut tells me") is effective in the situation of a senior advisor and a weakly structured problem. However, in the case of a junior advisor and more structured problems, System 2-type arguments (such as "the market research data tell me") work better.…”