The effect of cool water pack preparation on vaccine vial temperatures in refrigerators

Abstract

Cool water packs are a useful alternative to ice packs for preventing unintentional freezing of vaccines during outreach in some situations. Current guidelines recommend the use of a separate refrigerator for cooling water packs from ambient temperatures to prevent possible heat degradation of adjacent vaccine vials. To investigate whether this additional equipment is necessary, we measured the temperatures that vaccine vials were exposed to when warm water packs were placed next to vials in a refrigerator. We then calculated the effect of repeated vial exposure to those temperatures on vaccine vial monitor status to estimate the impact to the vaccine. Vials were tested in a variety of configurations, varying the number and locations of vials and water packs in the refrigerator. The calculated average percentage life lost during a month of repeated warming ranged from 20.0% to 30.3% for a category 2 (least stable) vaccine vial monitor and from 3.8% to 6.0% for a category 7 (moderate stability) vaccine vial monitor, compared to 17.0% for category 2 vaccine vial monitors and 3.1% for category 7 vaccine vial monitors at a constant 5 °C. The number of vials, number of water packs, and locations of each impacted vial warming and therefore percentage life lost, but the vaccine vial monitor category had a higher impact on the average percentage life lost than any of the other parameters. The results suggest that damage to vaccines from repeated warming over the course of a month is not certain and that cooling water packs in a refrigerator where vaccines are being stored may be a useful practice if safe procedures are established.

Using long-range freeze-preventive vaccine carriers in Nepal: A study of equipment performance, acceptability, systems fit, and cost

“…VVMs are stickers attached to vaccine vials that change color when exposed to heat over time [10] . This color change, which serves as a proxy for the degradation of heat-sensitive vaccines, can be described through equations that depend on the category of VVM [11] . These equations estimate the percentage of vaccine life that has been lost due to exposure to different temperatures—referred to as VVM life loss.…”

Evaluation of precipitation time of the aluminum salts adsorbed potentially frozen vaccines used in the Polish National Immunization Schedule for their pre-qualification before the administration

“…Many efforts are being undertaken worldwide to improve the functionality of the cold chain, as accidental freezing of vaccines is not only dangerous for the patients but also causes major budgetary losses. These efforts aim at three main goals: improvement of systems to monitor the temperature of thermo-sensitive vaccines, implementation of appropriate equipment to store and transport vaccines, and providing a sufficient number of adequately trained staff to handle vaccines [ 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 ].…”

Monitoring Suhu Chiller Berbasis Internet of Things Menggunakan Thermal Camera

“…Pada Rata-rata suhu objek dibandingkan dengan nilai batas suhu yang didapat setelah melakukan observasi, dimana menurut ASEAN-Japan Transport Partnership produk minuman harus disimpan pada suhu 5-18°C [1]. Sedangkan menurut WHO merekomendasikan vial yang berisi obat-obatan harus disimpan pada suhu 2-8°C [18]. Bila suhu objek lebih besar dari pada nilai batas suhu maka sistem akan menyalakan alarm.…”