The economic costs of the German participation in the Afghanistan war

Abstract

In this article, we estimate the total costs of the German participation in the Afghanistan war, both past and future. This is a hugely complex and uncertain calculation, which depends on several important assumptions. These assumptions pertain to the different cost channels and the shares of these channels that can be attributed to the German participation in the war. By calculating the costs of the German participation, we provide a framework for other researchers to do the same with respect to other countries. The article can function as a roadmap for researchers focusing on this topic. In the end we find that, in the most realistic of several possible scenarios regarding the duration and intensity of the German participation in the war in Afghanistan, the German share of the net present value of the total costs of the war ranges from 26 billion Euro to 47 billion Euro. These large ranges reflect the uncertainties with which the costs must be estimated. On an annual basis, we estimate that the German participation in the war costs between 2.5 and 3 billion Euro. This contrasts with the official war budget, which is little over 1 billion Euro for 2010, showing that governments may not adequately represent the costs of military action.

The economic costs of military conflict

“…VSL is higher in rich countries than poor countries; the poor are willing to pay less for their lives because they have less available to pay: a dollar to a poor person is worth much more than to a rich person. Stiglitz & Bilmes (2008) use $7.2 million per US life lost, while Brück, de Groot & Schneider (2011) use €2.05 million per German life. The low estimate of a German life relative to a US life proved controversial in Germany.…”

Micro-Level Dynamics of Conflict, Violence, and Development: A New Analytical Framework

“…3 For instance, Stiglitz and Bilmes (2008), Brück, de Groot and Bozzoli, (2012), Brück, de Groot and Schneider (2011), Knight, Loayza and Villanueva (1996), Collier (1999) and Stewart and FitzgGerald (2001).…”

What is war good for? Background ideas and assumptions about the legitimacy, utility, and costs of offensive war

“…Investments in other public goods, such as education and medical care-except for veterans-may also be postponed or canceled. One study found that each year of civil war reduces a state's growth rate by about 2.2% (Brück et al, 2011). Moreover, war has significant effects in areas near the war zone that are not themselves at war.…”