The Eastern Partnership: Soft Power Strategy or Policy Failure?

Nielsen, Kristian L.; Vilson, Maili

doi:10.54648/eerr2014012

Cited by 9 publications

(3 citation statements)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…Łapczyński, 2009;Tyushka & Schumacher, 2021), gradually much more focused on its security dimension (Christou, 2010), power-politics, and geopolitical implications (Crombois, 2019;E. Korosteleva, 2017;Nielsen & Vilson, 2014). At the level of the new MSs from CEE and their relationship to the EaP, not only have their approaches to the EaP been addressed (Adamczyk, 2010;Cianciara, 2009;Copsey & Pomorska, 2014;Tulmets, 2012), but their potential for a stronger position in the EU has been discussed, including their ability to influence its external direction (Dangerfield, 2009;Lamoreaux & Galbreath, 2008;Pastore, 2013).…”

Section: The Eap As a Part Of The Easternisation Of The Eu After Its ...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Enlargement of the EU Towards the East: A Pivotal Change in EU’s External Policy?

Dubský,

Kočí,

Votoupalová

2024

PaG

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The EU’s Eastern enlargement in 2004 was marked by the entry of mostly smaller states, whose ability to shape the external direction of the EU was questioned. However, the EU’s response to the war in Ukraine has shown how important the Eastern dimension of external policy is for the EU and that this Easternisation of the EU has occurred precisely in the wake of the 2004 enlargement. This is due to the fact that these states have been able to push their own narratives in the discourse on the EU’s Eastern direction, particularly in the case of the Eastern Partnership. This article analyses the discourse of Central and Eastern European states regarding the Eastern partnership, specifically the narratives of the official documents of three Baltic and four Visegrad group countries in the 2009–2022 period. The analysis made it possible to identify narrative structures and showed that the narratives are relatively similar in the selected countries. Despite the lack of cooperation between the two groups and the West’s neglect of the Eastern Partnership policy, they were able to individually strengthen their position in the EU and maintain the discussion about the Eastern Partnership at the EU level as a result.

show abstract

Section: The Eap As a Part Of The Easternisation Of The Eu After Its ...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Enlargement of the EU Towards the East: A Pivotal Change in EU’s External Policy?

Dubský,

Kočí,

Votoupalová

2024

PaG

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Previously, the lack of a reward (no membership perspective) for the effective implementation of EU-supported reforms was considered a crucial shortcoming of the initiative 69 . The limited possibilities of the Union's infl uence -through the programme -on the internal situation of the countries covered by it were also repeatedly emphasised (mainly the powerlessness against authoritarianism in Belarus and Azerbaijan or the pro-Russian turn in Armenia) 70 . The limited response to confl icts involving these states (lasting since 2014 war in eastern Ukraine or regular tensions between Yerevan and Baku) was also pointed out 71 .…”

Section: The Effectiveness Of Development Cooperation As a Tool For E...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Poland as a Democracy Exporter to the East? The Effectiveness of the International Role in the Example of Development Cooperation

Szynol

2023

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This article assesses the effectiveness of Poland’s development cooperation as a tool for realising the role of democracy (and broader – transition experiences) exporter. The assessment implements and adapts the framework presented by Justyna Zając, who indicated that an evaluation of the effectiveness of the international role must consider the rationality of its adopted concept, the feasibility and consistency of its implementation and the degree of its approval by other participants in international relations.

show abstract

“…In June 2008, the European Council officially requested the Commission to establish a proposal for an Eastern Partnership, mainly focusing on supporting regional cooperation and strengthening relations between the EU and its Eastern neighbours. A coherent policy framework for these countries as the EU's new eastern neighbours has become necessary (Nielsen and Vilson, 2014). In many cases, partner countries were facing everyday challenges with the Union.…”

Section: Eu's Eastern Partnership and Energy Transfer As A Russian Fo...mentioning

confidence: 99%

Economic opportunities or integrational challenges — The case study of Ukraine

Tankovsky

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The following dissertation discusses the Europeanization process of Ukraine and the challenges it will pose. Despite notable changes during the last six years, it still needs to be apparent whether Ukraine has its place in European integration. In 2022, candidate status has officially been provided to Ukraine, and many politicians are urging a fast-track membership. Despite the fact that war caused massive decrease in economic output, the country still has its huge potential and after the conflict it is likely that it will not return to the Russian interest zone; Ukraine’s only option is the EU, but it requires preparation form both sides. The main idea for this research arose from the geopolitical challenge faced by the post- Soviet countries. The work argues that a security-related evaluation should be added alongside the economic readiness evaluation for the Eastern Partnership countries to understand their assessment better. As the possibility of disintegration is also a real threat and a valid option in the coming years, external and internal challenges of Ukraine has been discussed as well. One of the goals of the research was to assess the recently executed reforms. Some of the positive aspects are: restored anti-corruption institutions, proper land reform that increased Ukraine's agricultural competitiveness, banking system have been reformed, de-oligarchisation law was created. All in all, during the last 3-4 years, long-awaited fundamental changes have started in the country and Zelensky still has the opportunity to continue this his way on this path. Another important goal of the writing was to assess Ukraine’s economic situation based on an adapted version of Palánkai’s framework. Overall, the integration analysis has shown beyond any doubt that Ukraine is not ready for European integration at the moment, as it has not been able to meet most of the criteria and expectations. It is worth mentioning that there have been positive changes in several areas, such as price liberalisation, international trade increased, IT sector was booming and corruption was decreasing. However, there are still severe shortcomings in competition policy, financial sustainability and macro stability, not even mentioning the available level of skilled labour which will be a huge challenge after the war ends. There is indeed a vast economic potential in Ukraine, but they could not use it for 30 years. Providing them immediate EU membership would cause further problems within the country's economic structures. They must eliminate most of their shortcomings, and the EU should help and supervise them. The third goal was to create a composite indicator and then apply it in the comparison between Ukraine and other EU candidate countries. Based on the result, Ukraine is behind not only the least developed EU Member States, but even many Western-Balkan countries are in better shape. With the assistance of the created composite indicator, the main economic aspects have been compared. Ukraine is an agricultural and industrial country with vast natural resources, in parallel the Balkan countries are a collection of small countries with diverse economies ranging from service-based to industrial and manufacturing-oriented. In terms of economic indicators, the Balkan countries and Ukraine differ significantly. The Balkan countries have a higher GDP per capita at PPP than Ukraine, and their economies have grown faster in recent years. The Balkan countries, particularly Serbia and Montenegro, have attracted noteworthy foreign investment in recent years, while Ukraine has struggled to attract foreign investment, with corruption and political instability being mainly barriers. Another relevant difference is their levels of entrepreneurship and innovation. The Balkan countries have a relatively high level of entrepreneurship and innovation, with many successful start-ups and technology companies emerging recently. Based on the findings, their situation differs from the Western Balkan countries. They are far from the maturity level that Montenegro and Serbia are already representing. Regarding the non-economic research of the work, the goal was to understand the external actor's roles and interests on the one hand, and present the internal obstacles that Ukraine is facing on the other hand. It is obvious that the American hegemony is declining, and more and more challenges are rising towards their global leading role. From the EU's side, a higher contribution is being demanded to its security as their bandwagoning strategy cannot be obtained anymore. It became clear after the breakout of the war that only with commercial relations it is not possible to ensure peace, the role of security has significantly increased in the international relations. Another important aspect is that the EU needs a more straightforward concept of how to deal with the Eastern Partnership countries. From Russia's perspective, these countries are part of their interest zone and willing to take even military actions to protect their influence. Nevertheless, there are also many concerning factors in Ukraine internally. Their identity seeking problem still is a significant challenge, and it is also an open question of how the oligarchic elite will react and behave themselves during the war. The already achieved results from the last 6-7 years are showing that the Ukrainians are determined in joining the EU and potentially NATO. If they will receive the necessary economic, military and legal support then their goals can be realized, it will only be a question of time. However, momentarily it would be a controversial decision to provide them fast-track membership in any cooperation. The most relevant limitations of the study were the following: limited scope - geopolitical aspects were missing; time constraints – the effects of COVID and the breakout of the full scale war were only partially covered; data accessibility – in this part of the world data collection is always a challenge. However, there are general limitations that the research could overcome: generalisability and challenges with replication. As a result of this work further researches can be conducted in the topic. First and foremost, the adopted integration maturity assessment can be used for other Eastern Partnership countries. In parallel, a similar composite indicator can be replicated for the political and institutional aspects. Another part of the topic that would worth to research is the geopolitical aspects of the question. The war in Ukraine can be seen as a challenge towards the unipolar system, it is basically a post hegemonial conflict. But it is a highly relevant question whether it will turn to a bi or multi poral one by the end of the decade. In this work there was no opportunity to discuss these significant questions, but its results could contribute to a further research related to the above mentioned problems.

show abstract

The Eastern Partnership: Soft Power Strategy or Policy Failure?

Cited by 9 publications

References 0 publications

Enlargement of the EU Towards the East: A Pivotal Change in EU’s External Policy?

Enlargement of the EU Towards the East: A Pivotal Change in EU’s External Policy?

Poland as a Democracy Exporter to the East? The Effectiveness of the International Role in the Example of Development Cooperation

Economic opportunities or integrational challenges — The case study of Ukraine

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About