To understand the consequences of prematurity on language perception it is fundamental to determine how atypical early sensory experience affects brain development. To date the neural oscillatory correlates in the time-frequency domain of voice processing as a function of atypical early sensory experience, as after premature birth, remain elusive. At term equivalent age, ten preterm and ten full-term newborns underwent high-density EEG recordings during mother or stranger speech presentation, presented in the forward (naturalistic) or backward order. A general group effect terms > preterms for the naturalistic mother's voice is evident in the theta frequency band in the left temporal area, where only full-term newborns showed an increased activity for the maternal voice, whereas preterm infants showed significant activation for stranger naturalistic speech. Similarly, a significant group contrast in the low and high theta in the right temporal regions indicates higher activations for the stranger speech in preterms. Finally, only full-term newborns presented a late gamma band increase for the maternal naturalistic speech, indicating a more mature brain response. The current study based on neural time-frequency patterns, demonstrates that preterm infants lack selective brain responses to the maternal naturalistic voice typical for full-term newborns, whereas preterms are selectively responsive to stranger voices in both temporal hemispheres.