The Discourse of Globalization: Framing and Sensemaking of an Emerging Concept

Abstract

While the literature on framing has importantly expanded our understanding of frame creation and contests from an interpretive point of view, previous studies have largely neglected the structural contexts in which framing activities occur. In this study, we propose extending the framing approach by incorporating insights from the literature on sensemaking to examine how and when opportunities for meaning creation open up and how this affects subsequent discursive processes. Connecting framing and sensemaking better enables us to examine how structural factors prompt and bound discursive processes, affecting when and where frame contests emerge. We demonstrate the utility of this approach by examining changes in the discourse of globalization. Using qualitative and quantitative analyses of newspaper articles and corporate press releases, we trace the emergence of globalization discourse, its diffusion, and the increasing contention that surrounds it. Our findings show how and where globalization discourse emerged in response to greater U.S. involvement with the international economy, and how later frame contests over the meaning of globalization have depended on the interests of the actors involved.

How Golden Parachutes Unfolded: Diffusion and Variation of a Controversial Practice

“…However, the mechanism for similarity is less clear here, whereas similarity to previous adoptions offers a clear theoretical rationale and empirical mechanisms (i.e., the ability to observe and learn about what parachutes were adopted previously). 5 Because our measure of media attention is considerably correlated with time (r = 0 83), we residualized this measure by regressing it on the linear time variable and then subtracting the predicted values from the measure's actual values, leaving it with only its unique variation, and assigning all confounded variation to the time variable, thus avoiding potential multicollinearity problems (Fiss and Hirsch 2005). Additional robustness checks confirmed that residualization itself has no substantive impact on the results.…”

The Role of Analogy in the Institutionalization of Sustainability Reporting

“…Our basic coding unit was a text segment, which we defined as a statement that was meaningful and that expressed a basic yet complete idea (see, for example, Fiss and Hirsch 2005). Aggregation of recurrent idea elements (Gamson and Modigliani 1989) expressed through the text segments yielded themes, or discursive strategies, used by the authors of the texts.…”

Institutionalization, Framing, and Diffusion: The Logic of TQM Adoption and Implementation Decisions among U.S. Hospitals

“…The results indicated a two-factor solution in which three of the four items showed very good loadings (.77-.96) and the fourth item (loss of market share) loaded on the predicted factor (economic losses) but also partially on the other (economic gains). We therefore residualized this measure to remove any shared variation with the second factor (e.g., Fiss & Hirsch, 2005). To do so, we regressed this item on the two measures of social and economic gains and then subtracted the predicted values from the actual values, leaving the measure with only its unique variation related to economic losses.…”