Lewis
acid catalysts have been shown to promote carbonyl–olefin
metathesis through a critical four-membered-ring oxetane intermediate.
Recently, Brønsted-acid catalysis of related substrates was similarly
proposed to result in a transient oxetane, which fragments within
a single elementary step via a postulated oxygen-atom transfer mechanism.
Herein, careful quantum chemical investigations show that Brønsted
acid (triflic acid, TfOH) instead invokes a mechanistic switch to
a carbonyl-ene reaction, and oxygen-atom transfer is uncompetitive.
TfOH’s conjugate base is also found to rearrange H atoms and
allow isomerization of the carbocations that appear after the carbonyl-ene
reaction. The mechanism explains available experimental information,
including the skipped diene species that appear transiently before
product formation. The present study clarifies the mechanism for activation
of intramolecular carbonyl–olefin substrates by Brønsted
acids and provides important insights that will help develop this
exciting class of catalysts.