Since the late 1970s numerous studies have explored students" approaches to learning (referred to as the "SAL" tradition).These studies have provided valuable evidence of students" study strategies and intentions at the university. Since extensive research already exists on students" approaches to learning, there is a need to move forward and analyse student learning from new perspectives. In the present in-depth qualitative study, we analyse interviews of 34 students who scored extremely highly on the deep approach scale in a pre-test in our previous quantitative study (Lindblom-Ylänne, Parpala & Postareff, 2013) and thus are likely to have a strong commitment to understand, and a "disposition to understand for oneself" which is a recently introduced, yet unexplored phenomenon (see Entwistle & McCune, 2009;McCune & Entwistle, 2011