The development of an herbal material quality control strategy considering the effects of manufacturing processes

Abstract

Background Quality by design (QbD) is an advanced drug quality control concept that has been gradually implemented in the optimization of manufacturing processes of Chinese medicines. However, the variation of Chinese medicinal material quality has rarely been considered in published works. Because manufacturing processes may lower the variation introduced through different batches of materials, a material quality control strategy should be developed considering the influences of manufacturing processes. Methods In this work, the processes of extraction, concentration, water precipitation, and chromatography for notoginseng total saponin (NTS) production were investigated while considering Panax notoginseng quality variation as a sample. Ten process parameters were studied simultaneously using a definitive screening design. After the process critical quality attributes (CQAs) were determined, critical process parameters (CPPs) and critical material attributes (CMAs) were identified simultaneously. Then, models utilizing the CMAs, CPPs, and process CQAs were developed. The design space was then calculated using a Monte Carlo simulation method with an acceptable probability of 0.90. A material quality control strategy considering the influences of manufacturing processes was proposed. Results The ginsenoside Rd purity and total saponin purity in the eluate were identified as process CQAs. The ethanol solution concentration used for extraction, the ethanol solution concentration used for elution, and elution time were identified as CPPs. The extractable dry matter content of Panax notoginseng was one of the CMAs. The extractable contents of notoginsenoside R1, ginsenoside Rg1, ginsenoside Rb1, and ginsenoside Rd were the other CMAs. The inequalities implemented to discriminate the high quality and low quality of Panax notoginseng were developed according to the NTS standard of the Xuesaitong injection. Low quality Panax notoginseng should not be released for NTS production. High quality Panax notoginseng can be treated with feasible manufacturing processing parameters. Verification experiments were carried out successfully for 2 batches of high quality Panax notoginseng. Conclusions In this work, a quality control strategy for herbal materials was developed considering the matching of process characteristics and material quality attributes. This strategy is promising for application to other Chinese medicines.

Market access of Chinese patent medicine products to healthcare security system in China: implications for international integration of traditional medicine into health systems

“…As general CPM products usually have several manufacturers to supply, bidding price often play the decisive role in final market access results. However, quality assurance will be the prerequisite factor for market access of generic CPM products, particularly considering the effects of manufacturing processes on CPM product quality [ 18 ]. In China, while quality standards for generic CPM products have been included into the China Pharmacopeia, the NMPA of China has not organized the consistency evaluation for generic CPM products yet [ 19 ].…”

An Index for Quantitative Evaluation of the Mixing in Ethanol Precipitation of Traditional Chinese Medicine

“…It is essential to improve the mixing of concentrate and ethanol solution to reduce losses arising from the coating. To the best of our knowledge, equipment factors [22], process parameters [23], and raw material characteristics [24] influence the mixing effect. Equipment factors include the mixing mode, size and shape of the stirring blade, and so on.…”

Analytical eco‐scale and quality by design‐oriented liquid chromatography method for simultaneous quantification of metoprolol succinate, telmisartan, and cilnidipine in their fixed‐dose combination

“…The QbD for analytical method development provides an option for continual improvement of method performance throughout the method life-cycle. For the past 5 years, scientifically justified and systematically optimized methods using QbD vouches for its suitability for various analytical purposes [10][11][12][13][14]. Hence, the authors combined the AES approach with QbD to develop a green analytical method to produce sustainable, robust method performance.…”