“…Rather, such scholars have argued that data-intensive technologies are implicated deeply in existing social relations, depend for their existence on a rich array of material factors, and cannot be considered in abstraction from the humans who design, deploy, and use them. More specifically, critical scholars have demonstrated how data-intensive technologies reinforce existing forms of discrimination (Katz, 2020;Noble, 2018) while undermining and complicating democratic processes (Sudmann, 2019), reconfiguring epistemologies (Kitchin, 2014;Lepage-Richer, 2021), and bolstering the pathologies of the capitalist mode of production, from ecological devastation to colonial predation of labor and resources (Chun, 2018;Crawford, 2021;Dyer-Witheford et al, 2019;Halpern, 2021;Verdegem, 2021). Others have pointed out how a self-reinforcing dynamic has developed between data and capital.…”