The Decision-Making Journey of Malaysian Women with Early Breast Cancer: A Qualitative Study

Abstract

Background: The survival outcomes for women presenting with early breast cancer are influenced by treatment decisions. In Malaysia, survival outcome is generally poor due to late presentation. Of those who present early, many refuse treatment for complementary therapy. Objective: This study aimed to explore the decision making experiences of women with early breast cancer. Materials and Methods: A qualitative study using individual in-depth interviews was conducted to capture the decision making process of women with early breast cancer in Malaysia. We used purposive sampling to recruit women yet to undergo surgical treatment. A total of eight participants consented and were interviewed using a semi-structured interview guide. These women were recruited from a period of one week after they were informed of their diagnoses. A topic guide, based on the Ottawa decision support framework (ODSF), was used to facilitate the interviews, which were audio recorded, transcribed and analysed using a thematic approach. Results: We identified four phases in the decision-making process of women with early breast cancer: discovery (pre-diagnosis); confirmatory ('receiving bad news'); deliberation; and decision (making a decision). These phases ranged from when women first discovered abnormalities in their breasts to them making final surgical treatment decisions. Information was vital in guiding these women. Support from family members, friends, healthcare professionals as well as survivors also has an influencing role. However, the final say on treatment decision was from themselves. Conclusions: The treatment decision for women with early breast cancer in Malaysia is a result of information they gather on their decision making journey. This journey starts with diagnosis. The women's spouses, friends, family members and healthcare professionals play different roles as information providers and supporters at different stages of treatment decisions. However, the final treatment decision is influenced mainly by women's own experiences, knowledge and understanding.

Appraisal of Breast Cancer Symptoms by Iranian Women: Entangled Cognitive, Emotional and Socio-Cultural Responses

“…Effective interactions were mainly achieved through consultation with professionals which together with relatives' support balanced undesirable emotional reactions and provided guidance and encouragement for serious follow-up. The overall outcome of social interaction, in line with other studies (Burgess et al, 2001;Lam et al, 2009;Lu et al, 2010;O'Mahony et al, 2011;Unger-Saldana and InfanteCastaneda, 2011;Abdullah et al, 2013), was perceived as supportive and very satisfying and led to informational and emotional support. Some consultants as shown in other studies (Gates et al, 2001;Unger-Saldana and Infante-Castaneda, 2011), offered false reassurance based on wrong information.…”

Comparison of Quality of Life of Turkish Breast Cancer Patients Receiving Breast Conserving Surgery or Modified Radical Mastectomy

“…Survival rates with BCS are similar to mastectomy (Ozmen, 2012;Abdullah et al, 2013). Survival rates of breast cancer have been increasing.…”

Determinants of Choice of Surgery in Asian Patients with Early Breast Cancer in A Middle Income Country

“…Mastectomy is the most common surgery and many women equate the diagnosis of breast cancer with a mastectomy (Taib et al, 2013). With increasing awareness, patients are presenting earlier and it is important to understand the decision-making process of Malaysian women in the choice of surgery (Abdullah et al, 2013).…”