The Critical Role of Review Criteria in Independent Peer Review

Isaac Asimov’s sci-fi novella “Profession” versus professionalism: Reflections on the (missing) scientific revolutions in the 21th century

“…Many publications discuss the history and role of peer review, its aspects, application in various scientific areas, alternatives, experiments or mechanism more or less critically (e.g.,Peters, Brighouse, Tesar, Sturm, Jackson 2023;Bedessem 2020;Hope, Munro 2019;Rigby, Cox, Julian 2018;Moghissi et al 2016;Chapelle 2014;Peters …”