The Covid-19 Learning Crisis as a Challenge and an Opportunity for Schools: An Evidence Review and Conceptual Synthesis of Research-Based Tools for Sustainable Change

Abstract

This paper advances our understanding of how schools can become change agents capable of transforming local practice to address the challenges arising from the Covid-19 pandemic. It presents a novel application of cultural-historical activity theory to reinterpret evidence on widespread learning loss and increasing educational inequities resulting from the pandemic, and to identify scalable transformative learning opportunities through reframing the crisis as a double stimulation. By reviewing evidence of the emerging educational landscape, we first develop a picture of the new ‘problem space’ upon which schools must act. We develop a problem space map to serve as the first stimulus to articulate local challenges. Integrating this problem space with research on professional change, we identify conceptual tools to capture learning gaps and implement pedagogic interventions at scale, in order to enhance schools’ agency in directly addressing the crisis. These tools can act as the second stimulus, enabling educators to address local challenges. We conclude by discussing the Covid-19 educational crisis as a unique stimulus for professional learning and outline the potential for durable shifts in educational thinking and practice beyond the pandemic. We argue that this unprecedented historic disruption can be harnessed as a transformative professional learning opportunity. In particular, we consider how research on professional change offers local, scalable interventions and tools that can support educators in preventing the new insights from ‘slipping away’ post-pandemic. Utilising the notions of boundaries and tool-mediated professional change, we examine the ways in which this disruption generates opportunities to envision alternative futures for equitable learning in school.

Patterns in Clinical Leadership Learning: Understanding the Quality of Learning about Leadership to Support Sustainable Transformation in Healthcare Education

“…As the authors in this Special Issue discuss, it is important for sustainability that educational organisations of different types conduct their own research on their practice and local learning objectives [107]. This requires practically feasible yet robust tools for local evidence-generation [108,109]. As the Leadership Learning Inventory proposed is very short (12 items in total) and its outputs easy to analyse, it also lends itself well to practical use in local evaluation and continual enhancement of leadership PD provision by a range of stakeholders in policy and practice contexts without requiring academic researchers' input.…”

A primary school head teacher’s experience of pressure to join a multi-academy trust

“…First, who is paying for this marketing and promotion of each MAT? Surely, this money and time spent could be used to support the learning of pupils, providing food to the most vulnerable or providing a few more hours of catch-up tuition so desperately needed since COVID-19 (Hofmann et al, 2021). Second, are these meetings a productive use of MAT senior leadership teams' time, when they are paid by us taxpayers to develop the educational outcomes of the pupils in their current care, not those at other schools?…”

A Theory-Led Evaluation of a Scalable Intervention to Promote Evidence-Based, Research-Informed Practice in Schools to Address Attainment Gaps

“…Opportunity Areas are parts of the country with the lowest levels of social mobility, where a range of predominantly education-focused initiatives have been put in place since 2017 to improve social mobility. Overlaying these developments in these areas, and more widely, is the COVID-19 pandemic, which has significantly negatively contributed to exacerbating educational inequalities [15][16][17].…”