The Cost of Imagined Actions in a Reward-Valuation Task

Abstract

Growing evidence suggests that humans and other animals assign value to a stimulus based not only on its inherent rewarding properties, but also on the costs of the action required to obtain it, such as the cost of time. Here, we examined whether such cost also occurs for mentally simulated actions. Healthy volunteers indicated their subjective value for snack foods while the time to imagine performing the action to obtain the different stimuli was manipulated. In each trial, the picture of one food item and a home position connected through a path were displayed on a computer screen. The path could be either large or thin. Participants first rated the stimulus, and then imagined moving the mouse cursor along the path from the starting position to the food location. They reported the onset and offset of the imagined movements with a button press. Two main results emerged. First, imagery times were significantly longer for the thin than the large path. Second, participants liked significantly less the snack foods associated with the thin path (i.e., with longer imagery time), possibly because the passage of time strictly associated with action imagery discounts the value of the reward. Importantly, such effects were absent in a control group of participants who performed an identical valuation task, except that no action imagery was required. Our findings hint at the idea that imagined actions, like real actions, carry a cost that affects deeply how people assign value to the stimuli in their environment.

Pavlovian threat learning shapes the kinematics of action

“…In turn, motor preparation and movements are accompanied by increases in skin conductance ( Critchley, 2002 ). The correlation between arousal during learning and the subsequent invigoration of action also extends what is known on the relationship between emotion and action ( Moors et al, 2013 ; Blakemore and Vuilleumier, 2017 ), suggesting that, in addition to current affective experience influencing action ( Starita and di Pellegrino, 2018 ; Garofalo et al, 2019 , 2020 , 2021 ; Bertini et al, 2020 ; Ellena et al, 2021 ; Sellitto et al, 2022 ), also past affective experience can affect future motor responses.…”

Accuracy of EEG Biomarkers in the Detection of Clinical Outcome in Disorders of Consciousness after Severe Acquired Brain Injury: Preliminary Results of a Pilot Study Using a Machine Learning Approach

“…Indeed, partial deafferentations of cortical and subcortical areas can also produce EEG rhythms within slower bands [ 66 ]. In contrast, non-TBI DoC patients with a vascular etiology show more focal cortical and subcortical lesions, with structural connectivity relatively preserved [ 62 , 63 ], but altered motor and behavioral abilities [ 86 ]. Thus, different neuropathological and connectivity profiles may be responsible for diverse EEG patterns.…”

Mitochondrial Impairment: A Common Motif in Neuropsychiatric Presentation? The Link to the Tryptophan–Kynurenine Metabolic System

“…Currently, researchers are focusing on finding scientific frameworks for understanding the relationship between the molecular regulation of higher-order neural circuits and neuropathological alterations, and how this may lead to PFC dysfunction and to the symptoms of mental illnesses and comorbidity [ 124 ]. The deficit in control and motor inhibition [ 125 , 126 ], but also in motor imagery or in the suppression of on-going action [ 127 ], which depend on aberrant neural activity in the PFC associated with serious impulsivity problems, are characterized by psychopathological and psychiatric conditions including MDD, SCZ, obsessive–compulsive disorder (OCD), and PD [ 128 , 129 ].…”