The convergence between defence and care in mammals

Abstract

The motivations to protect oneself and others have often been seen as conflicting. Here, we discuss recent evidence that self-defensive mechanisms may in fact be recruited to enable helping of others. In some instances, the defensive response to a threat may even be more decisive in promoting helping than the response to a conspecific’s distress (as predicted by empathy-altruism models). In light of this evidence, we propose that neural mechanisms implicated in self-defence may have been repurposed through evolution to enable protection of others, and thus defence and care may be convergent rather than conflicting functions. Finally, we present and discuss a neural working model of the shared brain mechanisms implicated in defence of both self and others.