The Content, Quality, and Behavior Change Techniques in Nutrition-Themed Mobile Apps for Children in Canada: App Review and Evaluation Study (Preprint)

Abstract

BACKGROUND Children increasingly use mobile apps. Strategies to increase child engagement with apps include the use of gamification and images that incite fun and interaction, such as food. However, the foods and beverages that children are exposed to while using apps are unknown and may vary by app type. OBJECTIVE The aim of this study is to identify the app content (ie, types of foods and beverages) included in nutrition-themed apps intended for children, to assess the use of game-like features, and to examine app characteristics such as overall quality and behavior change techniques (BCTs). METHODS This analysis used a cross-sectional database of nutrition-themed apps intended for children (≤12 years), collected between May 2018 and June 2019 from the Apple App Store and Google Play Store (n=259). Apps were classified into four types: <i>food games</i> or nongames that included <i>didactic nutrition guides</i>, <i>habit trackers</i>, and <i>other</i>. Food and beverages were identified in apps and classified into 16 food categories, as recommended (8/16, 50%) and as not recommended (8/16, 50%) by dietary guidelines, and quantified by app type. Binomial logistic regression assessed whether game apps were associated with foods and beverages not recommended by guidelines. App quality, overall and by subscales, was determined using the Mobile App Rating Scale. The BCT Taxonomy was used to classify the different behavioral techniques that were identified in a subsample of apps (124/259, 47.9%). RESULTS A total of 259 apps displayed a median of 6 (IQR 3) foods and beverages. Moreover, 62.5% (162/259) of apps were classified as food games, 27.4% (71/259) as didactic nutrition guides, 6.6% (17/259) as habit trackers, and 3.5% (9/259) as other. Most apps (198/259, 76.4%) displayed at least one food or beverage that was not recommended by the dietary guidelines. Food game apps were almost 3 times more likely to display food and beverages not recommended by the guidelines compared with nongame apps (β=2.8; <i>P</i><.001). The overall app quality was moderate, with a median Mobile App Rating Scale score of 3.6 (IQR 0.7). Functionality was the subscale with the highest score (median 4, IQR 0.3). Nutrition guides were more likely to be educational and contain informative content on healthy eating (score 3.7), compared with the other app types, although they also scored significantly lower in engagement (score 2.3). Most apps (105/124, 84.7%) displayed at least one BCT, with the most common BCT being <i>information about health consequences</i>. CONCLUSIONS Findings suggest nutrition-themed apps intended for children displayed food and beverage content not recommended by dietary guidelines, with gaming apps more likely to display not recommended foods than their nongame counterparts. Many apps have a moderate app quality, and the use of consequences (instead of rewards) was the most common BCT.

Educational intervention for the promote behaviors related to oral health: a randomized trial protocol

“…Nowadays, considering that smartphones have become an integral part of daily life and many teenagers are now using mobile apps to monitor their lifestyle behaviors and improve their health, smartphones with content and games related to health behaviors may be a valuable platform to engage children, adolescents, and adults regarding nutritional behaviors, physical activity and prevention of chronic disease risk behaviors [4,23,24].…”

Educational intervention for the promote behaviors related to oral health: a randomized controlled trial protocol

“…In relation to the appropriate platform of health education for people, especially teenagers, it can be mentioned that smartphones have become an integral part of daily life and many teenagers are now using mobile apps to monitor their lifestyle behaviors and improve their health, smartphones with content and games related to health behaviors may be a valuable platform to engage children, adolescents, and adults regarding nutritional behaviors, physical activity and prevention of chronic disease risk behaviors [4,23,24].…”