The Complex Relationship of Realspace Events and Messages in Cyberspace: Case Study of Influenza and Pertussis Using Tweets

Abstract

BackgroundSurveillance plays a vital role in disease detection, but traditional methods of collecting patient data, reporting to health officials, and compiling reports are costly and time consuming. In recent years, syndromic surveillance tools have expanded and researchers are able to exploit the vast amount of data available in real time on the Internet at minimal cost. Many data sources for infoveillance exist, but this study focuses on status updates (tweets) from the Twitter microblogging website.ObjectiveThe aim of this study was to explore the interaction between cyberspace message activity, measured by keyword-specific tweets, and real world occurrences of influenza and pertussis. Tweets were aggregated by week and compared to weekly influenza-like illness (ILI) and weekly pertussis incidence. The potential effect of tweet type was analyzed by categorizing tweets into 4 categories: nonretweets, retweets, tweets with a URL Web address, and tweets without a URL Web address.MethodsTweets were collected within a 17-mile radius of 11 US cities chosen on the basis of population size and the availability of disease data. Influenza analysis involved all 11 cities. Pertussis analysis was based on the 2 cities nearest to the Washington State pertussis outbreak (Seattle, WA and Portland, OR). Tweet collection resulted in 161,821 flu, 6174 influenza, 160 pertussis, and 1167 whooping cough tweets. The correlation coefficients between tweets or subgroups of tweets and disease occurrence were calculated and trends were presented graphically.ResultsCorrelations between weekly aggregated tweets and disease occurrence varied greatly, but were relatively strong in some areas. In general, correlation coefficients were stronger in the flu analysis compared to the pertussis analysis. Within each analysis, flu tweets were more strongly correlated with ILI rates than influenza tweets, and whooping cough tweets correlated more strongly with pertussis incidence than pertussis tweets. Nonretweets correlated more with disease occurrence than retweets, and tweets without a URL Web address correlated better with actual incidence than those with a URL Web address primarily for the flu tweets.ConclusionsThis study demonstrates that not only does keyword choice play an important role in how well tweets correlate with disease occurrence, but that the subgroup of tweets used for analysis is also important. This exploratory work shows potential in the use of tweets for infoveillance, but continued efforts are needed to further refine research methods in this field.

Using Social Media for Emergency Response and Urban Sustainability: A Case Study of the 2012 Beijing Rainstorm

“…It was demonstrated that the trend fitted well with the time line of the major events related to the Marseille Fire. In other works [32][33][34], observable correlations between tweets aggregated by time intervals and disease occurrences were found to be statistically significant. This further suggested the feasibility of using social media text streams as an analogue to different types of events in our society.…”

Tanning bed burns reported on Twitter: over 15,000 in 2013

“…The growing popularity of Twitter among teenagers and young adults may provide opportunities for understanding indoor tanning behaviors and resulting injuries. The social networking service has been used to track the spread of infectious diseases such as influenza [11], H1N1 [12], pertussis [13], and foodborne illness [14]. Similar to foodborne illnesses, acute health consequences of tanning bed use, such as burns, are not routinely monitored or reported.…”

Global Disease Monitoring and Forecasting with Wikipedia

“…These activity traces are embedded in search queries [36,, social media messages [77][78][79][80][81][82][83][84][85][86][87][88][89][90][91][92], and web server access logs [34,72,93]. At a basic level, traces are extracted by counting query strings, words or phrases, or web page URLs that are related to the metric of interest, forming a time series of occurrences for each item.…”

“…When appropriately trained, these methods can be quite accurate; for example, many of the cited models can produce near real-time estimates of case counts with correlations upwards of r = 0.95. The collection of disease surveillance work cited above has estimated incidence for a wide variety of infectious and noninfectious conditions: avian influenza [52], cancer [55], chicken pox [67], cholera [81], dengue [50,53,84], dysentery [76], gastroenteritis [56,61,67], gonorrhea [64], hand foot and mouth disease (HFMD) [72], HIV/AIDS [75,76], influenza [34,36,54,57,59,62,63,65,67,68,71,74,[77][78][79][80]82,83,[85][86][87][88][89][90][91][92][93], kidney stones [51], listeriosis [70], malaria [66], methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) [58]<...>…”