The Coach Phenomena: Examining the Validity of the Kolb Educator Role Profile in Preservice Agricultural Education

Abstract

Over the last three years, agricultural educators have demonstrated a strong preference for the coaching role, as defined by the Kolb Educator Role Profile (KERP). The purpose of this collective case study was to better understand why this dominant coach preference exists in Oklahoma preservice agricultural educators. Kolb Educator Role Profile (KERP) results, and semi-structured interviews to understand the choice rationale of preservice agricultural educators, were coded to determine the assessment’s qualitative validity. Two theoretical themes to address key issues emerged: (a) KERP theoretical perspectives and (b) espoused theories. An adapted KERP framework reflects the case’s diverging conceptualizations. Four theoretical categories describe the educator roles in agricultural education: (a) the friend, (b) the know-it-all, (c) the sounding board, and (d) the career development event (CDE) coach. Two theoretical categories capture conceptualization of learning modes: (a) student-first versus book-knowledge focus and (b) dialogue versus hands-on focus. Espoused theories of the preservice agricultural educators reveal KERP item statements were chosen that (a) reflect how I was taught, (b) connect to what I am good at, (c) involve action and real-world, (d) let agricultural education be different, (e) focus on personal growth of students, (f) are what I think students like, and (g) I understand. Recommendations for both improved validity and practice are provided.

The Impact of Furniture Arrangement upon Experiential Learning in Architectural Design Studios, with Reference to Cairo, Egypt

“…Recently, Kolb added another study in 2017 about the role of educators in the strategy. So, Kolb's strategy has covered a lot of studies that make his learning strategy updated [17][18][19]. For those reasons, David Kolb's learning strategy is chosen to be tested in this study.…”

Teaching Psychomotor Skills in a Virtual Environment: An Educational Case Study

“…The Educator Role Profile (ERP) was developed to assist educators in applying ELT concepts by matching teaching methods to the learning cycle [10,11]. The focus of the ERP is the role educators play interacting with, rather than on, students and includes four key styles and associated strategies: facilitator, subject matter expert, evaluator, and coach [12]. Educators adopt roles to help learners move around the learning cycle.…”