Terminal RNA uridylyltransferases (TUTases) catalyze templateindependent UMP addition to the 3 hydroxyl of RNA. TUTases belong to the DNA polymerase  superfamily of nucleotidyltransferases that share a conserved catalytic domain bearing three metal-binding carboxylate residues. We have previously determined crystal structures of the UTP-bound and apo forms of the minimal trypanosomal TUTase, TbTUT4, which is composed solely of the N-terminal catalytic and C-terminal base-recognition domains. Here we report crystal structures of TbTUT4 with bound CTP, GTP, and ATP, demonstrating nearly perfect superposition of the triphosphate moieties with that of the UTP substrate. Consequently, at physiological nucleoside 5-triphosphate concentrations, the protein-uracil base interactions alone are not sufficient to confer UTP selectivity. To resolve this ambiguity, we determined the crystal structure of a prereaction ternary complex composed of UTP, TbTUT4, and UMP, which mimics an RNA substrate, and the postreaction complex of TbTUT4 with UpU dinucleotide. The UMP pyrimidine ring stacks against the uracil base of the bound UTP, which on its other face also stacks with an essential tyrosine. In contrast, the different orientation of the purine bases observed in cocrystals with ATP and GTP prevents this triple stacking, precluding productive binding of the RNA. The 3 hydroxyl of the bound UMP is poised for in-line nucleophilic attack while contributing to the formation of a binding site for a second catalytic metal ion. We propose a dual role for RNA substrates in TUTase-catalyzed reactions: contribution to selective incorporation of the cognate nucleoside and shaping of the catalytic metal binding site.crystal structure ͉ nucleotidyl transferase ͉ RNA editing ͉ Trypanosoma ͉ terminal RNA uridylyltransferase poly(A) polymerase T erminal RNA uridylyltransferases (TUTases) are phylogenetically widespread and functionally divergent enzymes that catalyze template-independent transfer of UMP residues to the 3Ј hydroxyl group of RNA (1). TUTases belong to the polymerase  nucleotidyltransferase superfamily, which is characterized by the presence of the signature motif hG[G/S]X9-13Dh[D/E]h (X, any; h, hydrophobic amino acids) (2) and also includes poly(A) polymerases (PAPs), ATP(CTP):tRNA nucleotidyltransferases, terminal deoxy nucleotidyltransferases, protein nucleotidyltransferases, 2Ј-5Ј oligo(A) synthetases, and antibiotic resistance nucleotidyltransferases (3). TUTase activities have been reported in mammalian cells, plants, and parasitic protists from the order Kinetoplastida, Trypanosoma brucei, and Leishmania ssp. (1). Extensive uridine insertion/deletion editing in mitochondria of trypanosomatids requires 3Ј uridylylation of guide RNAs by RNA editing TUTase 1 (RET1) (4) and insertion of Us into messenger RNAs by RNA editing TUTase 2 (RET2) (5, 6). In addition to mitochondrial RNA editing TUTases, TUT3 (7) and TUT4 (8), cytoplasmic uridylyl transferases have been reported in T. brucei. Human cells apparently possess several ...