The Challenges of Understanding Fluid in Fluid Density

Abstract

Teachers' understanding of science concepts must be deeper than just factual knowledge. They need to understand how the facts are connected and relate to the natural world. Weather, ocean currents, and tectonic movement are all phenomena listed in the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS). Although understanding density of fluids within fluids is not directly mentioned in the NGSS, students need to understand fluid density in order to explain these common yet complex phenomena. We extended a familiar science activity of making a density column in order to help teachers understand the expectations of NGSS. Understanding the causes of the phenomena is critical for teachers. We found when students do not understand, they are more likely to substitute concrete or active causal factors, such as weight or force. We issued to our teachers the following challenge: "Make a density column with these 4 mystery liquids." As our students were in the process of determining the correct order to add the liquids, we noticed they confused mass and viscosity with density. In light of the expectations of the NGSS, we need to change the way teachers are prepared. They need time and space to practice connecting the concepts in practice. Therefore, teachers need help to connect the concepts to past experiences as well as time to reflect and revise. Teachers need to develop a mindset as a lifelong learner powered by their reflections and drive to help students understand science.

Development of Virtual Simulation to Reduce the Number of High School Students' Misconceptions about Fluid Topics

“…This shows that media use in learning is essential (Potvin & Cyr, 2017). Virtual media simulations are expected to make students who have misconceptions about a static fluid material experience a conflict of conceptions they have to allow the change of concepts into scientific knowledge (Petrosino & Mann, 2017;Purwanto et al, 2018).…”

Kemampuan Berpikir Kritis Siswa SMA pada Materi Fluida Statis

“…6, Bln Juni, Thn 2019, Hal 731-737 menganggap bahwa tekanan hidrostatis dipengaruhi oleh volume zat cair atau bentuk wadah, bukan dipengaruhi oleh kedalaman atau massa jenis zat cair (Berek, Sutopo, & Munzil, 2016). Penelitian lain menunjukkan bahwa ketika siswa menyelesaikan masalah tentang aplikasi hukum Archimedes, pada pokok bahasan terapung, melayang dan tenggelam, siswa lebih fokus pada konsep berat sebagai faktor yang memengaruhi keadaan benda ketika berada di dalam zat cair dan mengabaikan faktor massa jenis yang dimiliki oleh zat cair (Petrosino & Mann, 2017). Kesulitan yang sering dialami siswa disebabkan oleh adanya bentukan gagasan awal siswa yang menyimpang dari konsep fisis yang diberikan (Wijaya, Supriyono Koes, & Muhardjito, 2016;Young & Meredith, 2017;Petrosino & Mann, 2017) sehingga siswa dapat memiliki pemikiran sendiri yang menyimpang dari konsep sebenarnya (Sulasih, Suparmi, & Sarwanto, 2017).…”