The challenges of reshaping disease specific and care oriented community based services towards comprehensive goals: a situation appraisal in the Western Cape Province, South Africa

Abstract

BackgroundSimilar to other countries in the region, South Africa is currently reorienting a loosely structured and highly diverse community care system that evolved around HIV and TB, into a formalized, comprehensive and integrated primary health care outreach programme, based on community health workers (CHWs). While the difficulties of establishing national CHW programmes are well described, the reshaping of disease specific and care oriented community services, based outside the formal health system, poses particular challenges. This paper is an in-depth case study of the challenges of implementing reforms to community based services (CBS) in one province of South Africa.MethodsA multi-method situation appraisal of CBS in the Western Cape Province was conducted over eight months in close collaboration with provincial stakeholders. The appraisal mapped the roles and service delivery, human resource, financing and governance arrangements of an extensive non-governmental organisation (NGO) contracted and CHW based service delivery infrastructure that emerged over 15–20 years in this province. It also gathered the perspectives of a wide range of actors – including communities, users, NGOs, PHC providers and managers - on the current state and future visions of CBS.ResultsWhile there was wide support for new approaches to CBS, there are a number of challenges to achieving this. Although largely government funded, the community based delivery platform remains marginal to the formal public primary health care (PHC) and district health systems. CHW roles evolved from a system of home based care and are limited in scope. There is a high turnover of cadres, and support systems (supervision, monitoring, financing, training), coordination between CHWs, NGOs and PHC facilities, and sub-district capacity for planning and management of CBS are all poorly developed.ConclusionsReorienting community based services that have their origins in care responses to HIV and TB presents an inter-related set of resource mobilisation, system design and governance challenges. These include not only formalising community based teams themselves, but also the forging of new roles, relationships and mind-sets within the primary health care system, and creating greater capacity for contracting and engaging a plural set of actors - government, NGO and community - at district and sub-district level.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12913-015-1109-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Using a mHealth system to recall and refer existing clients and refer community members with health concerns to primary healthcare facilities in South Africa: a feasibility study

“…Importantly, this mHealth intervention enabled LHWs to receive instructions and report progress while in the community, which could translate to important gains in process timing. These advantages have also been noted in other mHealth studies [9,23,50]. However, the low recall and referral success rates, and the challenges highlighted in the qualitative data, suggest that the implementation of mHealth interventions in the 'real world' primary healthcare services is challenging.…”

“…Currently, LHWs play a critical role in extending the PHC system into communities [5]. South Africa has approximately 72,000 LHWs organised in ward-based outreach teams [9]. They perform a variety of tasks, such as medication administration, child health surveys, referring people with illness symptoms to facilities, and recalling clients to for various reasons, for instance, to receive tests results or medication [10].…”

ART adherence clubs in the Western Cape of South Africa: what does the sustainability framework tell us? A scoping literature review

“…In SA, lay counsellors fall under the category of community healthcare worker where the funding comes both from government and donors . Their scope of practice is vague and lacking in definition and standardization . This may increase the risk of insufficient training and dependence on government priorities .…”

Moving towards universal health coverage: Strengthening the evidence ecosystem for the South African health system

“…[57] Drawing on leadership and governance conceptual frameworks from the social policy sector, and through primary research and case studies of provincial CHW programmes and the adoption and implementation of the wardbased outreach teams, SA scientists have now identified the key leadership and governance roles and the tasks required in reforming and governing national CHW programmes. [58][59][60] This empirical work has been synthesised into a framework that systematises and organises the tasks of CHW programme governance, and serves as 'actionable' guidance for stewards of these programmes. [61] The evidence ecosystem (Fig.…”