The challenges of designing a benchmark strategy for bioinformatics pipelines in the identification of antimicrobial resistance determinants using next generation sequencing technologies

Abstract

Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) technologies are expected to play a crucial role in the surveillance of infectious diseases, with their unprecedented capabilities for the characterisation of genetic information underlying the virulence and antimicrobial resistance (AMR) properties of microorganisms. In the implementation of any novel technology for regulatory purposes, important considerations such as harmonisation, validation and quality assurance need to be addressed. NGS technologies pose unique challenges in these regards, in part due to their reliance on bioinformatics for the processing and proper interpretation of the data produced. Well-designed benchmark resources are thus needed to evaluate, validate and ensure continued quality control over the bioinformatics component of the process. This concept was explored as part of a workshop on "Next-generation sequencing technologies and antimicrobial resistance" held October 4-5 2017. Challenges involved in the development of such a benchmark resource, with a specific focus on identifying the molecular determinants of AMR, were identified. For each of the challenges, sets of unsolved questions that will need to be tackled for them to be properly addressed were compiled. These take into consideration the requirement for monitoring of AMR bacteria in humans, animals, food and the environment, which is aligned with the principles of a “One Health” approach.

Genomics for Molecular Epidemiology and Detecting Transmission of Carbapenemase-Producing Enterobacterales in Victoria, Australia, 2012 to 2016

“…Analyzing genomic data to infer relationships between isolates is complex. Many variables affect the number of measured SNPs between patients, including species, sequence type, assembly quality, reference sequence selected (and relatedness to isolates being analyzed), number and diversity of isolates analyzed, time between samples, masking of recombination and/or phage elements, sequencing technology, tools employed, and SNP-calling parameters (49, 50). As such, the potential SNP “threshold” proposed by this study (pairwise SNPs below a certain number suggesting possible transmission; in this case, ≤23 SNPs) may only apply to our data set and workflows, and hence it is always important to interpret genomic data in parallel with local epidemiological data (51–53).…”

Genetic Diversity, Biochemical Properties, and Detection Methods of Minor Carbapenemases in Enterobacterales

“…Indeed, the presence of a gene does not necessarily prove its expression. That is the reason why in silico antibiogram is not widely used yet ( 178 ). However, this method is able to detect any gene related to β-lactamases whatever its homology or phenotype as well as undetected or totally novel β-lactamase family.…”

A crash course in sequencing for a microbiologist

“…4Overview of the different steps involved in the use of NGS technologies for data gathering and utilization. After Angers-Loustau et al (2018), modified…”