Following the confirmation that both 2-chloropyrrole (1.) and 2-bromopyrrole (2) were unstable species, a number of 1-alkyl-and C-alkyl-2-halopyrroles were synthesized to investigate the range of instability. The l-alkyl-2halopyrroles synthesized were 2-chloro-1 -methylpyrrole ( 14), 2-bromo-l-methylpyrrole (15), l-benzyl-2-chloropyrrole (47), and l-benzyl-2-bromopyrrole (46). The C-alkyl-2-halopyrroles synthesized were 5-chloro-2-methylpyrrole (26), 2-tertbutyl-5-chloropyrrole (36), 5-chloro-2,3,4-trimethylpyrrole (29), and 5-bromo-2,3,4-trimethylpyrrole (20). Also synthesized were the 1-methyl derivatives of 26 and 29. Electrophilic substitution of 2-chloroand 2-bromopyrroles (1 and 2) under the conditions for formylation and diazo coupling was examined. In the case of the latter reaction no crystalline compounds could be isolated, but diazo coupling of 2-chloro-1 -methylpyrrole ( 14) gave rise to exclusive a substitution. Formylation of 2-chloropyrrole (1) gave the «-substituted derivative but 2-bromopyrrole (2) gave a product arising from the displacement of bromine, 5-chloropyrrole-2-carboxaldehyde (28), in addition to 5-bromopyrrole-2-carboxaldehyde (41).Electrophilic substitution of simple pyrrole derivatives occurs regioselectively at the 2 position2 and at a rate considerably faster than in the furan and thiophene series.3 The simple electrophilic substitution reactions such as nitration,4 sulfonation,5 and formylation6 therefore give rise to the 2-substituted product almost2 to the exclusion of the 3-substituted derivative. In all cases these products are well-characterized compounds with clearly defined physical constants.7 However, 2-chloropyrrole (1) and 2-bromopyrrole (2), the expected products of halogenation, are poorly characterized compounds. In addition, there is evidence that these compounds are quite unstable.Mazzara and Borgo,8 using sulfuryl chloride in ether as the chlorinating agent, were the first to report the synthesis of 1. Attempted isolation indicated that both l8 and 2,5dichloropyrrole (3)9 were probably labile. This observation was supported by the work of Hess and Wissing,10 who heated the pyrrolyl Grignard (4) reagent11 with chlorine in ether and obtained a highly unstable yellow oil. More recently, a Russian group6 prepared 2-chloropyrrole (1) but no comment was made as to the stability of the product. Further evidence for the instability of 2-chloropyrrole (1) comes from the work of Hodge and Rickards.12 Decarboxylation of 5-chloropyrrole-2-carboxylic acid (5) under re-