The autoclavable semirigid thoracoscope: the way forward in pleural disease?

Abstract

Medical thoracoscopy is a valuable tool in the investigation and management of pleural disease. It has considerable advantages over conventional blind pleural biopsy and videoassisted thoracoscopic surgery. Despite this, the practice of this technique in the UK is limited. Most operators use the rigid thoracoscope, which may be an unfamiliar instrument to respiratory physicians. A semirigid thoracoscope is available but its use has not been possible in the UK as it requires sterilisation with ethylene oxide, which is not approved in this country. The present authors describe herein their experience with the first ever autoclavable semirigid thoracoscope.Medical thoracoscopy using the new instrument was performed in 56 patients between June 2004 and May 2006. All patients had been referred with a unilateral pleural effusion of unknown aetiology, where blind pleural aspiration had failed to yield an answer. Diagnostic samples were taken and talc poudrage performed where appropriate.The instrument was easy to handle and excellent views were obtained. Histologically adequate biopsy samples were obtained in 54 patients. The combination of clinical features, computed tomography findings and thoracoscopic biopsy enabled a definite diagnosis in 49 (90.7%) of these patients. There were no complications.The autoclavable semirigid thoracoscope has immense potential in the diagnosis and management of pleural disease. Its diagnostic yield in pleural disease is comparable to the conventional rigid thoracoscope. It is similar in design to the fibreoptic bronchoscope and respiratory physicians should be able to adapt to its use easily. It is also compatible with existing video processors and light sources available in most endoscopy suites. The fact that this instrument is autoclavable should open the field for its use in the UK as well as in other countries.

Talc Pleurodesis for the Management of Malignant Pleural Effusions in Japan

“…We used a flexi-rigid thoracoscope in this study, which has the advantage of being able to reach narrow spaces more easily with its bidirectional flexible tip that allows for pleural fluid aspiration and biopsy under visualization from a single port of entry. Flexirigid thoracoscopy is primarily performed to diagnose pleural effusions of unknown cause (11)(12)(13). Previously, we described the use of thoracoscopic talc poudrage under flexirigid thoracoscopy with one port of entry and a dedicated catheter (14).…”

Semirigid thoracoscopy in the diagnosis of pleural effusion: first four cases in Turkey

“…Alınan biyopsi parçalarının küçüklüğü nedeniyle tanı oranının düşebilecek olması da diğer bir sınırlayıcı durum olabilir. Ancak Munavvar ve arkadaşlarının 56 olguluk serisinde %90.7 tanıya ulaşılmıştır (11). Bizim dört olguluk serimizde tanı oranımız %75'tir.…”

Research in Thoracoscopy (Pleuroscopy)

“…This combination ensures flexibility for better inspection of the pleural cavity and, at the same time, improves biopsy sampling with the rigid part. The diagnostic accuracy of flex-rigid thoracoscopes in cases of undiagnosed pleural effusion is the same as for rigid devices (on average 93%) (8,9). Although a recent study showed equal results in diagnostic accuracy with a rigid device, further large comparative studies are needed to confirm the results (1).…”