The Association of Direct Observation of Medical Students With Patient-Centered Care for Obesity

Abstract

Background and Objectives: Teaching medical students patient-centered approaches to weight loss counseling occurs in myriad ways. We examined lectures and direct faculty observation to see which was associated with better patient-centered care in medical students, measured by both self-perception and independent observer evaluation. Methods: Third- and fourth-year students attending one medical school were surveyed regarding their education in (1) weight loss and health behavior counseling, (2) obesity stigma, and (3) whether they had experienced direct faculty observation of their weight loss counseling. Several weeks later, the students were observed during a standardized patient encounter for obesity and an obesity-relevant comorbidity. A postencounter survey assessed overall student satisfaction with the encounter and with the care they provided. Independent coders rated their patient-centered communication using a validated measure. Results: There was no consistent association between any dependent variable and student ratings of adequacy of instruction, nor with instructional content. Direct faculty observation was not associated with overall encounter satisfaction or their overall patient-centeredness. However, experiences with direct faculty observation were significantly and positively associated with students’ perceptions of patient engagement (b=0.1, P=.05), and with independent coders’ ratings of student friendliness (b=0.13, P=.01), responsiveness (b=0.113, P=.03), and lower student anxiety (b=-0.1, P=.01). Conclusions: Independent observation and self-report of instruction adequacy and content had no consistent association with care quality. However, direct faculty observation predicted improvement in both student self-reports and independent observer ratings of students’ interpersonal quality of care. Further work is needed to define optimal methods of imparting patient-centered care.

The Impact of Specific Teaching Methods on Communication and History Taking in Second Year Medical Students

“…We performed a literature review to investigate which teaching tools have been shown to be effective in prior studies. 5,[9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19] Additionally, the teaching tools needed to be convenient to perform in the hospital setting and be in accordance with the guidelines of our hospital and college. The six teaching tools used by the faculty included:…”

The Role of Primary Care in Improving Population Health

“…Many practitioners, patients, and observers have witnessed how the craft of generalism, 64 , 72 , 84 as manifested in primary care, influences the health of real people over time in ways that collectively lead to improved population health. Complex system models 85 , 86 and theories 87 , 88 can help to convey how health emerges at the level of the person and population by paying attention to related factors on the ground, but many times, that complexity is most easily shared through stories.…”

Being There: The Importance of Direct Observation in Resident Assessment

“…Based upon this notion and a significant number of reports in the literature about the importance and superiority of direct observation, I have changed what I do when evaluating residents. [3][4][5] On an inpatient service, I minimize all other commitments so that I am present on the ward for almost the entire day and evening. This allows me to see almost all patients on admission with the residents and to be present when acute events occur.…”

“…Encounter cards and checklists have also been developed to aid in direct observation. 5,6 It is a privilege to be a faculty preceptor. My experience suggests that being present in the training space promotes best practices in all competencies.…”