The Association Between Occupational Exposure to Hand–Arm Vibration and Hearing Loss: A Systematic Literature Review

Abstract

Background Hearing loss is one of the most prevalent worker health conditions worldwide. Although the effect of noise exposure on hearing is well researched, other workplace exposures may account for significant hearing loss. The aim of this review was to determine whether occupational hand–arm vibration exposure through use of power or pneumatic tools, independent of noise exposure, is associated with permanent hearing loss. Do workers suffer from hand–arm vibration–induced hearing loss? Methods Peer-reviewed articles published in English between 1981 and 2020 were identified through five online databases with five search keywords. Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses guidelines, including online database search methodology, study selection, article exclusion, and assessment of potential study design confounders and biases, were followed. Results Database searches retrieved 697 articles. Fifteen articles that reported 17 studies met the criteria for review. All but two studies revealed statistically significant associations between occupational exposure to hand–arm vibration and hearing loss. The majority of the study results revealed associations between hand–arm vibration and hearing loss, independent of potential age and noise confounders. Conclusion Few studies have examined the association between occupational exposure to hand–arm vibration and hearing loss. Dose response data were limited as only one study measured vibration intensity and duration. Although the majority of studies identified statistically significant associations, causal relationships could not be determined. Further research using standardized and uniform measurement protocols is needed to confirm whether the association between occupational exposure to hand–arm vibration and permanent hearing loss is causal and the mechanism(s).

Coexposure to Solvents and Noise as a Risk Factor for Hearing Loss in Agricultural Workers

“… 57 Similar to solvents, hand-arm vibration may be another occupational exposure missed when studying hearing loss among working populations, especially among agricultural workers. 58 …”

Proposal of Combined Noise and Hand-Arm Vibration Index for Occupational Exposure: Application to a Study Case in the Olive Sector

“…Other studies in the same research topic led to similar conclusions. Duan D. P. et al [ 22 , 51 ] detected the increased risk of adverse effects on hearing function when the worker is additionally exposed to vibration under the same noise conditions in the workspace. In the same sense, other authors such as Pettersson et.…”

Noise Induced Hearing Loss and Tinnitus—New Research Developments and Remaining Gaps in Disease Assessment, Treatment, and Prevention

“…Self-reported hearing-loss symptoms in oil refinery workers were found to correlate with increased hearing loss at both low and high frequencies, suggesting that self-reported symptoms provide early signs of NIHL [ 10 ]. Furthermore, the use of handheld power and pneumatic tools from chain saws to dentistry equipment that expose workers to both noise and vibration in the upper body are considered hazardous to hearing [ 11 , 12 , 13 ]. Workers in most countries must comply with workplace regulations regarding noise exposure.…”