Abstract:Noticing is integral to the everyday practice of nurses; it is the pre-cursor for clinical reasoning, informing judgement and the basis of care. By noticing the nurse can pre-empt possible risks or support subtle changes towards recovery. Noticing can be the activity that stimulates action before words are exchanged, pre-empting need. In this article, the art of noticing is explored in relation to nursing practice and how the failure to notice can have serious consequences for those in care.
“…The literature indicated that nursing students need the necessary support to understand and articulate what they notice and to recognize its relevance. [34,38] The clinical instructor can coach students throughout the clinical day while undertaking patient care responsibility and during the post-conference when debriefing and reflecting on daily encounters. Students' active engagement in these debriefings will enhance the "narrative-reflective" reasoning pattern, [32] formally identified by Tanner [34] as the "narrative" reasoning style.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Engagement in clinical judgment parallels what other authors have termed as "noticing". [23,38] Noticing is the ancestor for both clinical reasoning and clinical judgment. It is only possible when students link clinical experiences with formal learning and knowledge of the particular patient's patterns of responses.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…It is only possible when students link clinical experiences with formal learning and knowledge of the particular patient's patterns of responses. [38] Poor attention to patients' needs and modest communication are the factors hampering these processes. [38] Linking students with more experienced nurses who are able to effectively mentor or precept will add to the previous interventions.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…[38] Poor attention to patients' needs and modest communication are the factors hampering these processes. [38] Linking students with more experienced nurses who are able to effectively mentor or precept will add to the previous interventions. Preceptors can draw students' attention to not only the technical aspects of care, but also to the social and emotional subtleties that, when noticed, will prevent unnecessary patient suffering.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Preceptors can draw students' attention to not only the technical aspects of care, but also to the social and emotional subtleties that, when noticed, will prevent unnecessary patient suffering. [38] This may require assigning students their own caseload, while maintaining their supernumerary status, rather than using them as nursing assistants. [40] The effective preceptorship or clinical teaching strategies will subsequently strengthen deep thought processes to establish clinical judgment in nursing students.…”
Background: Nursing educators need to determine educational strategies that will enable nursing students to reach effective and timely clinical judgments. Aim: This study documents how a combination of the constructivist approaches of concept-based learning and concept mapping impacts nursing students' clinical judgment skills. Methods: The study utilized a pretest post-test design to collect data from a convenient sample of all students who commenced adult health nursing courses at a private university in Jordan (N = 40). An observation of the performance aspects of clinical judgment of engagement, background, process, and representation utilizing a four-point Students Performance Aspects of Clinical Judgment Scale (SPACJS) was performed. Results: Except for the engagement aspect, all other aspects of clinical judgment showed significant improvements by the end of the courses. Moreover, overall clinical judgment ability significantly improved as the courses concluded. Conclusion: When the SPACJS and the constructivist approaches are respectively institutionalized as a clinical evaluation tool and as teaching strategies, students will receive specific feedback that will subsequently improve their engagement, background, process, and representation of future clinical judgment encounters. This feedback is relevant to specific concepts and cognitive maps will help students synthesize mental criteria against which future clinical encounters are reflected. As a result, students contextual clinical judgment maturity will be enhanced.
“…The literature indicated that nursing students need the necessary support to understand and articulate what they notice and to recognize its relevance. [34,38] The clinical instructor can coach students throughout the clinical day while undertaking patient care responsibility and during the post-conference when debriefing and reflecting on daily encounters. Students' active engagement in these debriefings will enhance the "narrative-reflective" reasoning pattern, [32] formally identified by Tanner [34] as the "narrative" reasoning style.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Engagement in clinical judgment parallels what other authors have termed as "noticing". [23,38] Noticing is the ancestor for both clinical reasoning and clinical judgment. It is only possible when students link clinical experiences with formal learning and knowledge of the particular patient's patterns of responses.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…It is only possible when students link clinical experiences with formal learning and knowledge of the particular patient's patterns of responses. [38] Poor attention to patients' needs and modest communication are the factors hampering these processes. [38] Linking students with more experienced nurses who are able to effectively mentor or precept will add to the previous interventions.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…[38] Poor attention to patients' needs and modest communication are the factors hampering these processes. [38] Linking students with more experienced nurses who are able to effectively mentor or precept will add to the previous interventions. Preceptors can draw students' attention to not only the technical aspects of care, but also to the social and emotional subtleties that, when noticed, will prevent unnecessary patient suffering.…”
Section: Discussionmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Preceptors can draw students' attention to not only the technical aspects of care, but also to the social and emotional subtleties that, when noticed, will prevent unnecessary patient suffering. [38] This may require assigning students their own caseload, while maintaining their supernumerary status, rather than using them as nursing assistants. [40] The effective preceptorship or clinical teaching strategies will subsequently strengthen deep thought processes to establish clinical judgment in nursing students.…”
Background: Nursing educators need to determine educational strategies that will enable nursing students to reach effective and timely clinical judgments. Aim: This study documents how a combination of the constructivist approaches of concept-based learning and concept mapping impacts nursing students' clinical judgment skills. Methods: The study utilized a pretest post-test design to collect data from a convenient sample of all students who commenced adult health nursing courses at a private university in Jordan (N = 40). An observation of the performance aspects of clinical judgment of engagement, background, process, and representation utilizing a four-point Students Performance Aspects of Clinical Judgment Scale (SPACJS) was performed. Results: Except for the engagement aspect, all other aspects of clinical judgment showed significant improvements by the end of the courses. Moreover, overall clinical judgment ability significantly improved as the courses concluded. Conclusion: When the SPACJS and the constructivist approaches are respectively institutionalized as a clinical evaluation tool and as teaching strategies, students will receive specific feedback that will subsequently improve their engagement, background, process, and representation of future clinical judgment encounters. This feedback is relevant to specific concepts and cognitive maps will help students synthesize mental criteria against which future clinical encounters are reflected. As a result, students contextual clinical judgment maturity will be enhanced.
Observing interprofessional simulation David Boud Students undoubtedly experience far more opportunities to observe a variety of interprofessional interactions in health care settings than they will ever have the chance to practice. This demands that the ability to learn from observation should be accorded a high priority in any course. It also implies that particular attention needs to be given to the role of simulations in promoting skills of observation as these are situations in which the role of observation can be directly influenced and acted upon, unlike the vicissitudes of opportunistic practice. However, developing skilled observation is not enough. Students need also to be able to respond to what they observe. At the very least they need to be able to formulate strategies to appropriately address the situations they identify, but they need also to be able to translate these plans into what is potentially actionable, and ultimately, act on them.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.