The ambiguous relationship between practice variation and appropriateness of care: an agenda for further research

Abstract

The analysis of variation in the use of health care services, and particularly of practice variation, has been the subject of renewed interest because of the view that the inappropriate use of procedures could be a major cause of these differences. In this article, recent literature is reviewed and the results of personal research are described on both the variation in care provision and on appropriateness assessment. In the few studies which have focussed on both subjects no evidence has yet been found to suggest that practice variation is to be explained by differences in appropriateness rates. However, there are still many methodological pitfalls in both variation analyses (statistical problems) and appropriateness assessment (reliability of the judgement), implying that this conclusion is far from definitive. More research should therefore be conducted on methodological questions of variation analysis and appropriateness assessment. Furthermore in variation analysis the relative contribution of all potential determinants has to be studied on the various levels of care provision. Finally, to study the relationship between practice variation and appropriateness of care, the clinical problem and not the procedure should be the starting point.

Whom Should We Profile? Examining Diabetes Care Practice Variation among Primary Care Providers, Provider Groups, and Health Care Facilities

“…Profiling is viewed as a way to contain costs and control practice variation in hopes of improving the quality of care. Inevitably, the focus on practice variation moved from the geographic level to the hospital and health plan level and then to the individual provider in an attempt to understand the reasons for variation and to assign accountability (Wennberg 1998;Ashton et al 1999;Gatsonis et al 1995;Casparie 1996;Kassirer 1994;Corrigan and Nielsen 1993;Hanchak and Schlackman 1995;Evans, Hwang, and Nagarajan 1995;Eddy 1998).…”

The Eye of the Beholder: A Case Example of Changing Clients' Perspectives Through Involvement in the Model Validation Process

“…Hence, there is a large potential demand for cataract surgery. The complex interaction between supply and demand influences the number of cataract treatments (Casparie, ). Better insight into the structure between demand and supply is needed (Tuulonen, ).…”

Rationale Therapie

“…2/3 der Patienten angemessen ist [3]. B. Verschreibungen unnötiger Medikamente, Doppeluntersuchungen usw.).…”