“…Aerosol indirect effects can be grouped into two categories: the first indirect effect, or Twomey effect (Twomey, 1977), by which enhanced concentrations of cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) enhance CDNC (for a fixed liquid water content), leading to an increase in cloud albedo; and the lifetime, or Albrecht effect (Albrecht, 1989), by which enhanced CDNC suppresses precipitation and leads to thicker or more persistent clouds and higher cloud albedo. The first indirect effect has been supported by numerous empirical studies relating remotely sensed aerosol properties to remotely sensed CDNC Gryspeerdt et al, 2016;Patel et al, 2017;Quaas et al, 2008Quaas et al, , 2009Matsui et al, 2006;Nakajima et al, 2001;Sekiguchi et al, 2003), although whether aerosol affects cloud lifetime is still debated (McCoy et al, 2017b;Malavelle et al, 2017;Gryspeerdt et al, 2016;Mace and Avey, 2016). Studies have utilized the natural laboratory provided by transient degassing volcanoes to study cloud responses to changes in aerosol (Mace and Abernathy, 2016;Gassó, 2008;Yuan et al, 2011;Malavelle et al, 2017; Mc-…”