The Administration of Muslim’s and Non-Muslim’s Ownerless Estate (Bona Vacantia) in West Malaysia: An Analysis

Abstract

In Malaysia, if a deceased passed away intestate (without leaving a valid will) and no next of kin is available, his or her estate is deemed as an ownerless estate (bona vacantia). However, bona vacantia has not been classified, identified, and examined clearly, particularly in terms of the various sets of law applicable to the non-Muslims and Muslims in West Malaysia. Therefore, this paper intends to examine the classification of estates categorised under bona vacantia, its position in both Islamic law and Malaysian law, and the issues associated with the topic. The doctrinal analysis is adopted by analysing the current primary and secondary materials which include case law, statutory provisions, and other legal and non-legal literature. Consequently, the administration of bona vacantia is found to be governed by different procedures and laws, based on the personal law of the deceased. If he is a Muslim, his estate will be reverted to Baitulmal. Meanwhile, the type of estate left by a deceased non-Muslim will determine the reversion of such estate, either to the Government or the State Authority.

Analysing the Loopholes on Estate Administration of Cryptocurrency in Malaysia

“…It should be noted that a dual system has been implemented in Malaysia in relation to estate matters, depending on the deceased's personal laws where the Federal Constitution states that intestate, testate, and succession issues for Muslims are governed and determined by Islamic law. Non-Muslim estates, on the other hand, are governed by specific Acts such as "the Civil Law Act of 1956", "the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act of 1971, and the Distribution Act of 1958" (Halim et al, 2019). Significant losses may continue to have an adverse effect on the country's economic growth in the absence of proper estate administration of cryptocurrency, as Md.…”

Bibliometric Examination of "Bona Vacantia": Charting Patterns and Research Trends

“…A study by Halim et al (2019) examined the administration of Bona vacantia for Muslims and non-Muslims in West Malaysia, revealing distinct legal frameworks and procedures across states. Baitulmal receives both movable and immovable Bona vacantia estates for Muslims, while the YDPA fund receives movable properties for non-Muslims, and the State Authority takes responsibility for immovable properties (Halim et al, 2019). Notably, the adequacy of these laws has not been thoroughly discussed.…”