The Acquisition of L2 Listening Comprehension Skills in Primary and Secondary Education Settings: A Comparison Between Clil and Non-Clil Student Performance

Abstract

This study explores the impact of CLIL (Content and Language Integrated Learning) on the development of listening skills in English both in Primary and Secondary Education in Spain. To do this, CLIL (n=2,790) and non-CLIL learners (n=17,070) enrolled in the 4 th grade of Primary Education (9-10 years old), and CLIL (n=2,680), and non-CLIL students (n=17,638) in the 2 nd year of Secondary Education (13-14 years old) were compared regarding their oral comprehension skills. Results showed no differences between CLIL and non-CLIL groups in Primary Education, while in Secondary School, the CLIL group significantly outperformed the non-CLIL group in the overall results of listening and in every oral comprehension subskill evaluated, and differences were higher in the most complex listening tasks. These findings seem to suggest that CLIL programs are more effective to promote the acquisition of listening skills in the target language in secondary than in primary school settings. The age of students, along with other contextual differences between the CLIL programme in Primary and in Secondary School might explain these results.

Students’ content learning in Science in CLIL vs non-CLIL classes in Greece

“…Overall, the results of these studies highlighted the positive effect of CLIL instruction on students' L2 development (Hughes & Madrid, 2020). Researchers reported better overall language ability for CLIL learners (Jexenflicker & Dalton-Puffer, 2010;Lorenzo & Moore, 2010), superior academic language and language complexity (Maillat, 2010), improved writing skills (Gené-Gil, Juan-Garau & Joana Salazar-Noguera, 2015; Jexenflicker & Dalton-Puffer, 2010), listening comprehension (Dallinger et al, 2016;Nieto Moreno de Diezmas, 2018), reading skills (Pérez- Vidal & Roquet, 2015), as well as greater oral fluency and creativity in speaking skills and interaction (Admiraal et al, 2006;Nieto Moreno de Diezmas, 2016).…”