Cl complexes-catalyzed enantioselective transfer hydrogenation of pyridyl ketone 7 as the key step, and the sense of asymmetric induction of 2-pyridyl ketone 7 is opposite to that of normal ketones in the transfer hydrogenation. Our results confirm the correctness of the determination of the absolute configuration by three physical chemistry methods, and, unbelievably, the erroneous assignments by all previous five asymmetric syntheses.