Testicular Torsion in the Medicolegal Perspective: Why is the diagnosis missing?

Abstract

BACKGROUND: By examining patients with testicular torsion (TT) that caused problems in medicolegal terms, the present study aims to define markers causing medical neglect or malpractice in similar conditions and perform a retrospective examination to characterize the medical aspects of patients with TT. METHODS:In this study, 53 patients who underwent orchiectomy for TT following interventions made between 2004 and 2019 in different hospitals of Turkey and had satisfactory clinical findings in their files based on medicolegal inspections were included. RESULTS:The median age of the patients was nine years. Twenty-three (43.4%) of the patients had TT on the left side, 29 (54.7%) had TT on the right side, and one (1,9%) patient had bilateral TT. It was noticed that 31 (58.5%) patients had epididymo-orchitis (EO), seven patients had (13.2%) urinary infection, five (9.4%) patients had a hydrocele, and four (7.5%) patients had renal colic, and the others had testicle contusion, gastroenteritis, inguinal hernia, and acute appendicitis as misdiagnoses. The mean time that passed between admission and TT diagnosis was detected as 59±11.2 hours. A statistically significant relation was detected between the branch of the physician who first evaluated the patients and the presence of performing scrotal examination and imaging during admission. The ratio of physical scrotal examinations by emergency service physicians was lower than with the urologists. Among the preliminary examiner allowed to be an advanced evaluation for the possibility of missing diagnosis by an independent specialist physicians, 25 (47.2%) were urologists, 22 (41.5%) were emergency service physicians, four (7.5%) were pediatricians, and two (3.8%) were radiologists. CONCLUSION:Physicians should perform the required evaluations for a suitable diagnosis and treatment by putting aside their medicolegal concerns and prevent the problems by giving priority to patient health. For the correct diagnosis and proper management of TT, it is necessary to increase the information levels of physicians, and patients should be explored urgently in the event of any clinical suspicion.

Protective effect of Smilax excelsa L. pretreatment via antioxidant, anti‐inflammatory effects, and activation of Nrf‐2/ HO ‐1 pathway in testicular torsion model

“…inflammation, oxidative stress, Smilax excelsa L., testis torsion illnesses (Sharp et al, 2013;Taşçı et al, 2021). Intravaginal torsion, which arises when the tunica vaginalis is not firmly fixed to the surrounding tissues during the perinatal phase, accounts for the bulk of testicular torsion cases (Stoykov et al, 2020).…”

“…Orchiectomy is performed 42% of the time in boys who have testicular torsion. Since the treatment necessitates surgery and may result in organ loss, a clear diagnosis should be obtained promptly for separating it from other scrotal illnesses (Sharp et al, 2013; Taşçı et al, 2021). Intravaginal torsion, which arises when the tunica vaginalis is not firmly fixed to the surrounding tissues during the perinatal phase, accounts for the bulk of testicular torsion cases (Stoykov et al, 2020).…”

Comparison of hematological markers between testicular torsion and epididymo-orchitis in acute scrotum cases

“…The two most important pathologies resulting in acute scrotum manifestation are TT and EO, which need to be clearly differentiated since urgent surgical treatment is indicated for the former. Failure to diagnose TT is among major medicolegal issues in Turkey (11). Although TT can be seen at any age, it is more common in males below the age of 25 years (3).…”