Tension between Leadership Archetypes: Systematic Review to Inform Construction Research and Practice

Abstract

In the literature on construction projects, the role of project managers in maintaining control over tasks and activities has been theorised comprehensively, placing a firm focus on vertical forms of leadership. Increasingly, construction firms are challenged with unprecedented operational uncertainty, brought about by changes to project environments, technology and labour. Similar challenges in other contexts have led to growing research on shared or horizontal approaches to leadership, which have been particularly effective in making organisations more agile in uncertain environments. Through a systematic review of 289 peerreviewed articles on leadership in construction, this paper considers the extent to which traditional vertical approaches to leadership are supplemented with horizontal and emerging balanced approaches to leadership across six bodies of construction leadership research. It contends that despite evidence for the increasing implementation of horizontal leadership practices on construction projects, vertical leadership theory dominates construction leadership research. In comparison, there is a dearth of research addressing horizontal leadership and 2 scarce consideration of balanced leadership. Based on the review, stronger integration of the balanced leadership archetype in research on leadership in construction is proposed as a logical means of advancing leadership theory in relation to six research vectors.

Impact of women authentic leadership on their own mental wellbeing through ego depletion: moderating role of leader's sense of belongingness

“…According to authentic leadership theory, authentic leaders, have strong convictions, values and good morale, which influences followers' sense of belonging, potentially leading to compromised behavior owing to leader bias (Zheng et al, 2020). On the other hand, a leader's sense of belonging aids leaders in replenishing their ego and emotional resources, particularly when confronted with complex, dangerous and challenging situations (Graham et al, 2020). This…”

“…Today's construction sector faces a variety of socioeconomic, political and business development issues as a result of multiple corporate challenges in terms of competition and substandard business management practices, which has compelled the modern construction sector to prioritize leadership development (Abjorensen, 2019;Alade and Windapo, 2020;Graham et al, 2020). The construction sector is regarded a male-dominated industry due to its complexity, project emphasis and lack of safety and risk (Khan et al, 2020a, b).…”

Severity Assessment of Problems in Turkish Building Audit System: A Fuzzy AHP Approach

“…The second literature review was then conducted to identify the problems of Turkish BAS unfolded by researchers. During this literature review, the search engine Scopus was preferred since Scopus has long been known as one of the most comprehensive and effective search engines [35]- [37]. It should be noted that only peerreviewed research articles and papers presented in prestigious conferences were utilized to maximize the reliability of the framework.…”

The Emotional Machiavellian: Interactions Between Leaders and Employees

“…Construction firms in developing countries are challenged with both organisational and country-level uncertainties. Yet, leadership research in construction industries (Graham et al, 2020 ) in developing countries (Yap et al, 2019 ) is scarce.…”