Temporal Rhythms and Patterns of Electronic Documentation in Time-Critical Medical Work

Abstract

We examine nursing documentation on a newly implemented electronic flowsheet in medical resuscitations to identify the temporal patterns of documentation and how the recorded information supported time-critical teamwork. To determine when the information was documented, we compared timestamps from 58 flowsheet logs to those of verbal communications derived from video review. We also drew on observations of 95 resuscitations to understand the behaviors of nurse documenters. We found that only 8% of the verbal reports were documented in near real-time (one minute within the verbal report), while 42% of reports were not documented in the electronic flowsheet. In addition, 38% were documented early (before the verbal report) and 12% were documented with a delay, ranging from one to 58 minutes after the report. Our study showed that the electronic flowsheet design posed many challenges for realtime documentation, leading to paper-based workarounds and the use of free-text fields on the flowsheet to visualize and keep track of time, and to communicate temporal information to the team. These findings suggest that documenters shape the temporal rhythms of not only their own work but also the rhythms of the electronic record and medical process. We discuss the implications of these rhythms for EHR redesign to support real-time documentation in high-risk, safety-critical settings. CCS CONCEPTS • Human-centered computing~Field studies • Humancentered computing~Empirical studies in HCI

Timing errors and temporal uncertainty in clinical databases—A narrative review

“…Human perception of time is fallible ( 125 ), and accurate recollection of elapsed time may be impacted by exposure to stressful situations ( 126 – 130 ). The expectation that bedside providers deliver both direct care and simultaneously record the details of that care creates a need to chart interventions retrospectively ( 131 , 132 ), potentially requiring recall to determine exactly what time they occurred ( 133 , 134 ). This problem is exacerbated by the fact that the number and complexity of patient care related tasks increases with patient acuity ( 104 , 135 ).…”

Practice-Centered Approach to Design Cooperative Healthcare Information Systems: Data, Architectural and Organizational Challenges

“…. ) and redesign the workflow [32,33,34,35]. Those attempts changed the familiar activity flows which exacerbated the workloads of the healthcare professionals and created a time-consuming action [26,30,32].…”

“…Therefore, we argue that an HIS need to ensure that the users stay conscious about the urgent and imperious cases to which they need to respond quickly. Highlighting the urgent information, dedicating special views to contingencies, and offering a notification service is tremendously important to ensure this awareness's level [15,35].…”

Alerts as Coordination Mechanisms

“…While this shared leadership strengthens the overall team's competence, it may also complicate the team's work coordination and decision-making. Different technologies have been proposed, designed or evaluated to support emergency medical teamwork, including cognitive aids [15,16,23,31], smart devices [32], electronic flowsheets [20], and wall displays [24,30]. Some of these systems were designed for the entire team to support coordination and a shared understanding of the work process [24,31], while the other systems were only used by the leader [16].…”