“…The twentieth century studies of Miesel, Mu ¨ller-Kirchenbauer and Hanses [21,29,31] report very limited data on the development over time. More recently, several researchers studied pipe progression rates (dl/dt) experimentally [3,35,36,38,41,51]. Robbins et al [38] used cylindrical flumes and correlated progression rates to seepage velocity and void ratio.…”