Temporal aggregation impacts on epidemiological simulations employing microcontact data

Abstract

BackgroundMicrocontact datasets gathered automatically by electronic devices have the potential augment the study of the spread of contagious disease by providing detailed representations of the study population’s contact dynamics. However, the impact of data collection experimental design on the subsequent simulation studies has not been adequately addressed. In particular, the impact of study duration and contact dynamics data aggregation on the ultimate outcome of epidemiological models has not been studied in detail, leaving the potential for erroneous conclusions to be made based on simulation outcomes.MethodsWe employ a previously published data set covering 36 participants for 92 days and a previously published agent-based H1N1 infection model to analyze the impact of contact dynamics representation on the simulated outcome of H1N1 transmission. We compared simulated attack rates resulting from the empirically recorded contact dynamics (ground truth), aggregated, typical day, and artificially generated synthetic networks.ResultsNo aggregation or sampling policy tested was able to reliably reproduce results from the ground-truth full dynamic network. For the population under study, typical day experimental designs – which extrapolate from data collected over a brief period – exhibited too high a variance to produce consistent results. Aggregated data representations systematically overestimated disease burden, and synthetic networks only reproduced the ground truth case when fitting errors systemically underestimated the total contact, compensating for the systemic overestimation from aggregation.ConclusionsThe interdepedendencies of contact dynamics and disease transmission require that detailed contact dynamics data be employed to secure high fidelity in simulation outcomes of disease burden in at least some populations. This finding serves as motivation for larger, longer and more socially diverse contact dynamics tracing experiments and as a caution to researchers employing calibrated aggregate synthetic representations of contact dynamics in simulation, as the calibration may underestimate disease parameters to compensate for the overestimation of disease burden imposed by the aggregate contact network representation.

Instability of Suicidal Ideation in Patients Hospitalized for Depression: An Exploratory Study Using Smartphone Ecological Momentary Assessment

“…Each participant was provided with an Android smartphone for the duration of the study. Phones were installed with Ethica (Hashemian, Qian, Stanley, & Osgood, 2012;Knowles, Stanley, & Osgood, 2014) to facilitate data collection. This application employed four questions, each rated on a visual analogue scale from 0 to 100, designed to reflect the following constructs: depressed mood ("How depressed do you feel right now?…”

Investigating the Diffusion of Agent‐based Modelling and System Dynamics Modelling in Population Health and Healthcare Research

“…Second, the era of big data offers great opportunities in applying SS approaches to health research. More specifically, large volumes of data from various sources—such as government records, electronic health records, insurance claims, behavioral data from patient surveys and social media—have become available, which will provide more flexibility in model design, parameterization and validation (Hashemian et al ., ). In the end, we believe the combination of big data and systems science will create a new paradigm in health research in which existing evidence can be better explored and interventions and policies can be evaluated in a more cost‐effective manner.…”

Mitigation of epidemics in contact networks through optimal contact adaptation

“…Such study gives insights about the relationship between the proximity of individuals and the spread of flu. The authors in [20] studied the impact of the experiment design in collecting contact data and the duration of the study on the outcome of an epidemic spreading process. The authors illustrated the correlation between the dynamcis of empirical contact networks, the number of participants and the outcome of simulation models.…”