Technology diffusion: Shift happens — The case of iOS and Android handsets

Abstract

The diffusion of technology artifacts is often marked by abrupt events and incremental evolutionary moves, resulting in shifts in diffusion parameters as well as the underlying mechanics. In this paper, we model the diffusion of Android and iOS based handsets, where new models and operating system versions are released periodically. We relax a common assumption in IT diffusion studies, of holding diffusion parameters constant, and find that there are clear breaks in their values at specific points in time. Using the system dynamics methodology, we then develop and calibrate a causal model of the underlying mechanics. Significant events during evolution of the two platforms are matched temporally with the observed breaks, and the changing mechanics of diffusion across the breakpoints are identified using this causal structure. We find that iOS and Android handset diffusion patterns, although superficially similar, were driven by different mechanics. Our study contributes to the IT diffusion literature by (i) establishing the need to test for, and model, shifts in diffusion parameters over the horizon of interest (ii) offering a method to identify changes in diffusion mechanisms accompanying these shifts and (iii) demonstrating that similar temporal diffusion patterns need not imply similar underlying mechanics.

A Systematic Evaluation of Mobile Applications for Instant Messaging on iOS Devices

“…Mobile devices have become an essential tool in our daily lives [1], to the point that the number of mobile users has been increasing more and more in recent years, from 640 million of Android and iOS active devices in 2012 [2] to 2,562 million of devices in 2016 [3]. So considerable is this increase that in the summer of 2016 Apple reported the sale of its billionth iPhone [4].…”

The Impact of Integration on Application Success and Customer Satisfaction in Mobile Device Platforms

“…Together with Google's Android, iOS is one of the largest platforms when it comes to contributed third-party applications. From a research perspective, the platform offers various interesting governance and dynamics aspects, which is why iOS was involved in many studies already (Dutta et al 2017;Eaton et al 2015;Ghazawneh and Henfridsson 2013). Apple iOS with its single marketplace, AppStore, allows for coherent and exhaustive measurement of success and satisfaction metrics, which is important for this analysis and the reason why iOS was chosen.…”

“…Given the market structure for mobile device platforms, the Google PlayStore is used. Since the two platforms (iOS and Android) combined account for a market share of more than 95%, other platforms cannot be considered comparable (Dutta et al 2017). Furthermore, the two are often considered to be direct competitors for mobile devices platforms (Tilson et al 2012).…”

“…Platform owners regularly release updates of their platforms which introduce new features (Dutta et al 2017).…”

The Case of iOS and Android: Applying System Dynamics to Digital Business Platforms

“…Attempts to model digital business platforms using system dynamics are quite rare. Dutta et al use system dynamics to model the diffusion of iOS and Android based handsets [2]. Ruutu et al provide a system dynamics simulation model to analyse platform development and platform based competition [7].…”