Team communication patterns in emergency resuscitation: a mixed methods qualitative analysis

Abstract

BackgroundIn order to enhance patient safety during resuscitation of critically ill patients, we need to optimize team communication and enhance team situational awareness but little is known about resuscitation team communication patterns. The objective of this study is to understand how teams communicate during resuscitation; specifically to assess for a shared mental model (organized understanding of a team’s relationships) and information needs.MethodsWe triangulated 3 methods to evaluate resuscitation team communication at a tertiary care academic trauma center: (1) interviews; (2) simulated resuscitation observations; (3) live resuscitation observations. We interviewed 18 resuscitation team members about shared mental models, roles and goals of team members and procedural expectations. We observed 30 simulated resuscitation video recordings and documented the timing, source and destination of communication and the information category. We observed 12 live resuscitations in the emergency department and recorded baseline characteristics of the type of resuscitations, nature of teams present and type and content of information exchanges. The data were analyzed using a qualitative communication analysis method.ResultsWe found that resuscitation team members described a shared mental model. Respondents understood the roles and goals of each team member in order to provide rapid, efficient and life-saving care with an overall need for situational awareness. The information flow described in the interviews was reflected during the simulated and live resuscitations with the most responsible physician and charting nurse being central to team communication. We consolidated communicated information into six categories: (1) time; (2) patient status; (3) patient history; (4) interventions; (5) assistance and consultations; 6) team members present.ConclusionsResuscitation team members expressed a shared mental model and prioritized situational awareness. Our findings support a need for cognitive aids to enhance team communication during resuscitations.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12245-017-0149-4) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Does electronic decision support influence advanced life support in simulated cardiac arrest?

“…Other studies have found that decision support systems that support the whole team have the potential to enhance team performance, team communication and situational awareness. (28,29). Our participants, whilst accepting the merit of the second screen as a means of improving organisation and communication, some participants felt that the introduction of information resulted in loss of control and recommended that future devices should provide only the information that was required at that particular point in time.…”

Nonoperating room anaesthesia: safety, monitoring, cognitive aids and severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2

“…Unfamiliar staff, infrequent exposure to anaesthetic or perioperative emergencies, managing older or nonstandard equipment and isolation from colleagues may add to the cognitive load of the anaesthesiologist. Cognitive aids may help reduce this load, alleviate stress and provide a shared mental model for those staff members involved [49]. Hospital working conditions during pandemics such as SARS-CoV-2 are particularly challenging and it is exactly this environment in which cognitive aids may contribute to improved outcome for patients and HCWs.…”

Avoiding medication errors through effective communication in healthcare environment

“…The roles of each team member in the healthcare environment should be understood in order to provide rapid, life-saving and effective delivery of health services (Calder et al, 2017). Rajah et al (2017) also suggested standardized health literacy communication techniques guidelines for improving good healthcare delivery.…”